Welcome to White Rose Magazine.

We are Israel

The Land that Remained in the People: Judean Peoplehood, Indigenous Belonging + the Meaning of Zionism

Before debating Zionism, before invoking the Holocaust, and before entering the controversies of contemporary politics, we must begin with a more fundamental question: Who are the Jewish people, and what is the history of our enduring connection to the Land of Israel?

We are a people. Jews are an ethnocultural people whose historical origins lie in the ancient Israelites and Judeans, whose civilization emerged in the Land of Israel, and whose history remains bound to that ancestral homeland. Judaism is our religion, but Jewish identity has never been confined to religious belief or observance. It encompasses ancestry, history, language, culture, collective memory, and national belonging. We did not begin as a religious community that later acquired an attachment to a place. Our peoplehood and our connection to the land are intertwined from the beginning of our history.

Our connection to the Land of Israel long preceded modern Zionism and the State of Israel. Zionism gave modern political expression to an existing historical connection; it did not create it.

The land is etched into the people.

It is present in Hebrew, in the names of ancient places, in our prayers and calendar, and in the historical record of the ancient Israelite and Judean civilizations from which the Jewish people emerged. It is present in Jerusalem, not merely as a sacred symbol, but as a city at the heart of Jewish history and collective memory.

We did not acquire this connection because we were persecuted. We carried it through centuries in which we lacked the political power to determine our own national future in our ancestral homeland. Our national belonging did not arise from suffering, nor does it depend on proving that we have suffered enough to deserve a homeland. We were a people long before modern anti-Semitism, long before the Holocaust, and long before modern Zionism gave our national aspirations a new political form.

Jewish history is a story of extraordinary continuity, not immobility. Across Europe, North Africa, the Middle East, and beyond, Jewish communities developed distinct languages, customs, and intellectual traditions. They absorbed influences, adapted to changing circumstances, and contributed to the civilizations around them without losing the historical continuity that bound them to one another and to their ancestral homeland. Empires fell, borders shifted, and communities were dispersed, yet the connection to the Land of Israel endured across generations.

That continuity has a dimension beyond cultural memory: it is also reflected in ancestry. Modern genetic research has found evidence of shared ancestry among many Jewish populations, including ancestry connected to the Levant, alongside the effects of migration and admixture over centuries. Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Mizrachi Jews have distinct population histories, yet research reveals patterns of relatedness across many of these communities. We are a displaced family whose very biology remembers home.

Nor does the evidence rest on ancestry and memory alone. Archaeology provides a substantial material record of ancient Israelite and Judean life in the Land of Israel: inscriptions, buildings, coins, and other remains that illuminate the civilizations from which Jewish history emerged.

The Tel Dan Stele, discovered in northern Israel and dating to the ninth century B.C.E., contains an Aramaic reference widely read as the “House of David” (בֵּית דָּוִד), providing important extra-Biblical evidence of a Davidic dynasty.

Jerusalem’s Siloam Inscription, associated with a water tunnel generally dated to the eighth century B.C.E., describes workers excavating from opposite directions and meeting within the rock. Written in ancient Hebrew script, it preserves a vivid record of life in Jerusalem more than 2,700 years ago.

Ancient Judean coinage offers further evidence of national identity. Coins bearing the inscription “Y-H-D” attest to the name of the province of Yehud under Persian administration. Centuries later, during the First Jewish-Roman War (66–70 C.E.) and the Bar Kokhba revolt (132–135 C.E.), Jewish authorities issued coins inscribed with phrases such as “Freedom of Zion,” “The Redemption of Israel,” and “For the Freedom of Jerusalem.” These coins expressed Jewish political aspirations and the desire to reclaim sovereignty in a land bound to Jewish history.

Rome could destroy the Temple, suppress revolts, and scatter Jewish communities across its empire, but it could not sever the bond with our ancestral homeland. Through Torah and Talmud, prayer and law, Hebrew and ritual, the land remained a living inheritance. What political power could no longer sustain, Jewish civilization continued to carry.

Zionism was the modern political expression of that extraordinary continuity: not the invention of the Jewish people’s connection to its homeland, but the effort to give that connection renewed national and physical expression. For generations, the Jewish people had carried the land within its civilization. Zionism sought to re-establish Israel as our homeland in which our civilization could once again shape its collective future.

No single artifact tells the story of an entire people. But archaeology, language, literature, ritual, and the evidence of continuing Jewish life together illuminate a connection that modern Zionism did not create. Jewish communities continued to live in the Land of Israel under successive periods of foreign rule, even as their numbers, circumstances, and political standing changed. Their presence did not mean uninterrupted sovereignty; the loss of sovereignty did not erase their place in the history of their ancestral homeland.

The Land of Israel is not simply the place Jews remember. It is part of the history through which the Jewish people remembers itself.

Our relationship with this land is ancestral, historical, cultural, and religious, sustained across generations through language, ritual, learning, and collective memory.

The Jewish calendar offers a vivid expression of this continuity. Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot preserve associations with the agricultural seasons, pilgrimage, and the geography of the Land of Israel. Across continents and centuries, Jewish communities continued to observe these festivals, carrying the rhythms and memories of their ancestral land into places far removed from it.

Our national belonging did not arise from suffering, nor does it depend on proving that we have suffered enough to deserve a homeland. We were a people long before modern anti-Semitism, long before the Holocaust, and long before modern Zionism gave our national aspirations a new political form.

Hebrew offers another powerful expression of Jewish continuity. It remained the language of Jewish scripture, prayer, interpretation, and intellectual life even as its everyday use changed over the centuries. Its revival as a modern spoken language transformed this shared inheritance into a language of public life, giving ancient Jewish civilization renewed expression in modern national life.

Jerusalem remained at the heart of Jewish consciousness across generations. It lived in prayers, poetry, wedding ceremonies, and the words spoken at the conclusion of the Passover Seder: “Next year in Jerusalem.” The aspiration endured even among generations who had never seen the city.

Jewish communities continued to live in Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, Hebron, and elsewhere under changing political authorities. Their numbers and circumstances varied, but their presence formed part of the continuing history of Jewish life in our ancestral homeland.

Together, language, ritual, historical memory, communal life, and material evidence reveal the continuity of a people whose identity is historical, cultural, and national as well as religious.

A Charedi Jew in Jerusalem, a secular Jew in Tel Aviv, and an atheist Jew in New York may inhabit profoundly different intellectual and spiritual worlds. They may disagree about G-d, religious observance, politics, and the meaning of Jewish life. Yet each may understand themselves as belonging to the Jewish people. Their differences do not erase the history they share.

We are a people, not merely a faith.

The land endured in Jewish consciousness even when most Jews lived elsewhere. It was carried in words, practices, names, and expectations. The loss of political sovereignty altered the conditions of Jewish life; it did not dissolve the people whose history had begun there. Remembering a homeland and possessing the political freedom to shape its future are not the same thing.

For centuries, Jews preserved a distinctive collective identity while living under the authority of other states and empires. They developed institutions, cultivated intellectual traditions, and contributed enormously to the societies around them. Jewish life sometimes flourished; at other times, it faced discrimination, exclusion, expulsion, and violence. Throughout these changing circumstances, Jews generally lacked the political agency to determine their collective national future.

Emerging in the nineteenth century amid persistent anti-Semitism, modern Zionism sought to realize a longstanding aspiration: Jewish national self-determination in the Land of Israel.

Persecution helps explain the urgency of modern Zionism. It does not exhaust its meaning. To understand Zionism only as a response to anti-Semitism is to begin the story too late, making Jewish national self-determination appear to be a conditional remedy, justified only by the severity of Jewish suffering. The Jewish people’s national aspirations did not originate in persecution, and their legitimacy should not depend on proving how terribly Jews have suffered.

This brings us to a fundamental question of liberal political thought: can a philosophy committed to individual freedom also recognize the legitimate national aspirations of the ethnicities to whom individuals belong?

Modern Zionism can be understood within the intellectual tradition of liberalism, particularly its commitments to freedom of conscience, equality before the law, protection against arbitrary power, and self-government. These principles provide a compelling philosophical framework for understanding the claims of national liberation movements.

Human beings do not arrive in the world as isolated individuals without history. We inherit languages, traditions, and cultural identities. We belong to communities whose stories began before our birth and whose futures extend beyond our lives. We may reinterpret these inheritances, reject parts of them, or choose how to relate to them, but we do not create them from nothing. For centuries, the Jewish people lived under foreign rule, often without the political power to determine their collective future. Zionism emerged as a movement to reclaim the Jewish people’s right to national self-determination.

John F. Kennedy articulated a connection between Zionism and universal liberty in his 1960 address to the Zionist Organization of America, describing friendship for Israel as “a national commitment.” Martin Luther King, Jr. likewise connected Israel’s security with democratic values. Addressing the Rabbinical Assembly in 1968, he called Israel “one of the great outposts of democracy in the world.” King’s opposition to anti-Semitism also extended to anti-Zionism, as reflected in a 1967 conversation later recounted by sociologist Seymour Martin Lipset. Together, these statements illustrate how prominent American advocates of liberal and democratic ideals understood the significance of Israel, although their views should be understood in their historical context.

A universal principle cannot be universal only when its application is convenient.

Zionism belongs in a serious conversation about liberalism because it raises a fundamental question for liberal political thought: does freedom mean only the protection of individuals within existing political arrangements, or can it also include the capacity of a people to shape its own national future? For the Jewish people, that future has a particular historical geography. It is the Land of Israel.

National self-determination does not require a people to be culturally uniform, religiously observant, or politically unanimous. It recognizes that a people with a shared history and collective identity has a legitimate interest in shaping its own future. For the Jewish people, that aspiration is inseparable from the land in which our civilization emerged and with which our collective memory remains bound.

The Jewish experience also challenges the assumption that participation in a wider civilization must eventually mean the erosion of a distinctive identity. Jewish history is not a story of isolation. Jews have encountered other civilizations, absorbed influences, debated inherited traditions, and contributed to the societies in which they lived. These encounters have enriched Jewish intellectual, artistic, scientific, and political life. The question has never been whether Jews should engage with the wider world. It is whether engagement requires self-erasure.

The ancient encounter with Hellenistic civilization offers a revealing perspective. Following Alexander the Great’s conquests, Greek language, philosophy, education, and cultural practices spread throughout the eastern Mediterranean. Many Jews engaged deeply with Hellenistic culture, which profoundly shaped Jewish life.

Jewish responses varied. Some sought fuller assimilation into the dominant culture, even attempting to reverse their circumcisions to participate in Greek athletic institutions. They traded an eternal heritage for ephemeral social currency. Yet the conflicts that culminated in the Maccabean revolt reflected competing visions of Jewish life, not simply a struggle between everything Jewish and everything foreign.

Rome could destroy the Temple, suppress revolts, and scatter Jewish communities across its empire, but it could not sever the bond with our ancestral homeland.

The lesson is not that cultural influences must be rejected. Jewish civilization has never developed in isolation. The question is whether a people retains the confidence and freedom to decide what it will adopt, what it will transform, and what it must preserve.

Across the centuries, we, the Jewish people, accomplished something extraordinary: we endured. The empires that ruled over us rose and fell. We learned their languages, engaged with their ideas, contributed to their achievements, and made our homes within their societies. We were shaped by the worlds we inhabited, yet never wholly dissolved into them. Dynasties collapsed. Borders were redrawn. And still, we endured.

The civilizations changed. The world changed. The Judean people remained.

The question of how a people can belong fully to the wider world without losing its distinctive identity remains urgent in the modern West. Jews have helped shape Western intellectual, scientific, artistic, and political life. We can embrace its achievements, defend its liberal principles, and participate fully in its future without setting aside our history or Jewish national belonging. We need not choose between Jewish particularity and universal human dignity, or confuse integration with assimilation. A people can be open to the world without becoming indistinguishable from it.

The danger of over-assimilation is not that Jews learn from other civilizations, speak other languages, or make homes in other countries. It is that the desire to belong can pressure Jews to minimize, conceal, or abandon the inheritance that makes their identity distinctive.

In its contemporary form, this can be understood as a kind of Neo-Hellenism: the assumption that Jewish identity becomes more acceptable when its distinctive history and national aspirations are softened or set aside. Under this logic, Jews may participate in universal causes, provided their own particularity does not demand recognition. But universal human dignity does not require the erasure of the particular communities through which people experience history, culture, and belonging. Jews should not have to justify their own collective identity in order to affirm the rights and dignity of others.

We can be citizens of other countries, participate in other cultures, and contribute to the societies we call home. We can value their freedoms, criticize our own communities, reconsider our traditions, and disagree with one another. None of this requires us to deny our origins or abandon our relationship with our ancestral homeland. We can enter the wider world without disappearing into it.

The question is not whether Jews can belong to the West. We already do. It is why that belonging should require us to minimize our historical inheritance or apologize for our national aspirations.

A people should not have to become less itself to belong.

We did not become a people through persecution or acquire an ancestral homeland because we needed refuge. We were a people before modern Zionism, and our connection to the Land of Israel preceded the modern state.

On May 14, 1948, the establishment of the State of Israel gave Jewish national aspirations modern sovereign expression. Israel’s Declaration of Independence identified the Land of Israel as the birthplace of the Jewish people, where its spiritual, religious, and national identity had taken shape, and connected that historical relationship to the restoration of Jewish political freedom.

The state did not create the Jewish people, invent Hebrew, or establish Jerusalem’s place in Jewish memory. These were inheritances of a much older history.

What changed in 1948 was the political condition in which that history could unfold. Hebrew, preserved across generations in scripture, prayer, and learning, became a language of public institutions, education, government, and everyday life. Jewish cultural life could develop within a sovereign national home, and a people long accustomed to living across borders it did not control could assume direct political responsibility for its collective future.

Israel’s establishment was more than the creation of a state. It was the modern political expression of an enduring national identity.

The distinction between a people and its state remains essential. The Jewish people predates Israel, and Jewish life extends far beyond its borders. Diaspora communities remain vital to Jewish history and contemporary culture. Israel does not erase this reality; it gives sovereign expression to Jewish national life alongside the many ways Jewish identity flourishes elsewhere.

We are Israel.

Not because every Jew lives within Israel’s borders. Not because every Jew shares the same beliefs, traditions, or political convictions. Not because Jewish history is simple or the responsibilities of sovereignty small.

We are Israel because the history of the Jewish people and the Land of Israel are inseparable. Our connection is ancestral, historical, cultural, and religious, carried through language, memory, ritual, and generations of Jewish life. The loss of sovereignty did not erase our peoplehood. Time did not erase our origins.

We are Israel because we are a people, not merely a faith. Judaism is our religion, but Judean identity extends beyond religious observance. It belongs to the Charedi Jew in Jerusalem, the secular Jew in Tel Aviv, and the atheist Jew in New York; to Jews in Israel and those who make their homes elsewhere. Our differences do not erase the history we share.

We are Israel because we can participate in the wider world without surrendering our inheritance. We can be particular without being insular, rooted without being closed, and committed to our people’s future while recognizing the dignity and rights of others.

We are Israel because Zionism gives political expression to a fundamental conviction: that the Jewish people, like other peoples, is entitled to determine its national future in its ancestral homeland.

The land is etched into the people.

Not only in ancient stones and inscriptions, but in our language, traditions, place names, and the history through which we understand ourselves.

We did not become a people through persecution or acquire an ancestral homeland because we needed refuge. We were a people before modern Zionism, and our connection to the Land of Israel preceded the modern state.

The story of the Jewish people cannot begin with the Holocaust or be reduced to today’s political controversies. Those events matter profoundly, but they do not define our origins or exhaust the meaning of our national aspirations.

We are Israel: a people shaped by history, sustained through change, and responsible for the future we create.

The story did not begin in 1948.

And it does not end there.


I Am Not a Jew

I was born in Israel. I am a Sabra, my family is Yishuv Yashan—part of the Judean communities living in the Land of Israel for 2,000 years, after the Roman exile. I served 14 years in the IDF, and wrote a book about the oldest hatred in the world. And I am here to tell you today that I am not a Jew.

I am a Yehudi—Judean. I am an Ivri. And above all, I am a Yisraeli.

“Jew” is just what other people called us after they cut our land out of our name, and changed our name as a people, same as the Roman Emperor Hadrian changed the name of our land to Syria Palaestina in 135 C.E. After they spent the past 2,000 years raping, betraying, ghettoing, burning, and even making soap out of us, they subdued most of us and eventually pacified us to the point that today we have a large community of Jews who hate their homeland, historical capital, our G-d—but mostly hate themselves. Afraid of who they truly are—of being a Hebrew, a Yehudi. 

Let me show you how they did it, one letter at a time how they turned us into “Jews.”

In Hebrew, the word is Yehudi. It comes from Yehudah—Judah. Yehudah is a man, a tribe, a kingdom, and a land. The I at the end means “of.” A Yehudi is a man of Yehudah. The land sits inside the name.

Follow the word west. In Aramaic, it became Yehudai. In Greek, Ioudaios. In Latin, Iudaeus. So far you can still hear Judea in it. Then it reached Old French and became giu. The D fell out. From there it crossed to England, and in the late twelfth century it was written “Giw” and “Jeu.” The letter J only became the standard spelling in the sixteenth century. So the word “Jew,” the way you write it, is about 500-years-old. My people are 4,000-years-old.

Then English did one more thing. Yehudi was already the adjective. English froze the broken form as a noun, and, around the 1540s, it glued “-ish” onto it to make an adjective again. The suffix “-ish” is the English device denoting the inhabitants of nations: English, Danish, Irish, etc. It is also the suffix for “sort of”: greenish, childish, foolish. Remember that second meaning, because we will come back to it.

When Hadrian renamed Judaea “Syria-Palaestina” in 135, it was a specific, calculated insult designed to sever the linguistic and historical tie between the People (Israel) and the Land (Zion).

That was the first cut in our flesh. Hadrian erased the name of the land.

The languages of Europe made the second cut. They took the land itself out of the name they gave us. English comes from England. Polish comes from Poland. Jewish comes from Jew, but to an English-speaking ear, the Jew comes from nowhere, as Rome decreed it 2,000 years ago.

In 1950, Jordan did it a third time. It annexed Judea and Samaria and called them “the West Bank.” That is why today a Yehudi living in Yehudah is called a “settler.” Say it in Hebrew and hear how insane it is: a Judean is a foreigner in Judea.

Once the land is out of the name, four things become possible.

“Jew” is just what other people called us after they cut our land out of our name.

First, the word moves to the religion shelf. “Jewish” now sits next to “Christian” and “Muslim.” And from there they tell you: it is only a faith, anyone can convert, so you are not a people, so you have no land. A man told me exactly that last week. He compared us to Hindus. 

The truth is, in the first century, there was no such thing as Judaism as a portable, faith-based system. The term Ioudaismos (Judaism) referred to the entire way of life of the Judean people.

Second, the noun became the insult. Polite people say “Jewish person” because “Jew” feels rude in their mouth. We are the only people on earth whose name is avoided by those who are trying to be nice to us.

Third, “Jew-ish.” With a hyphen. Sort of a Jew. The diaspora made it a joke about itself: “I’m not Jewish, I’m Jew-ish.” There is a cookbook with that title from 2021. This is the Jew who treats his identity as a hobby, a nostalgia, or simply a flavor. Then in December of 2022 an American politician who was caught inventing a Jewish family said: “I never claimed to be Jewish. I am Catholic. Because I learned my maternal family had a Jewish background, I said I was ‘Jew-ish.’”

Fourth, once “sort of a Jew” exists, the hater has his argument ready. You are the “sort-of” ones. The real ones are someone else. That is the Khazar story, which I call “the flat earth of anti-Semitism.” It is the people who tell Hebrew speakers that they “don’t understand their own texts or ancient language.” And it is very old. Paul wrote in Romans: “For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly… but he is a Jew, which is one inwardly.” That is the first “Jew-ish” in history. The Book of Revelation finished the thought: “them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.”

Nobody can be “sort of” from Yehudah. You are either from there or you are not.

In the Gospel of John, the word Ioudaioi appears about 70 times, and almost every time it is the enemy of Christianity. That is where and when our name became a charge sheet.

The Qur’an made the same split with two names. Banu Isra’il for the ancient people of the book. Yahud for the living ones in front of you. Muslims still say it: the Israelites of the Bible are not you. This is the blood libel that Israelis are not “the real Jews.”

And Christendom took the name itself, Yehudah, wrote it as “Judas,” and made it the word for “traitor” in every European language.

Now look at what each language did with the same root.

In English, by 1600, “Jew” meant a “person who seeks gain by sordid means.” Then it became a verb, “to jew down.” Then “Jewboy.” Then “Jew” as an adjective, always said with a sneer. We see it online today in almost every attack by haters.

Yiddish had “Yid,” a word of respect between Jews. English took it as well, and, by 1874, it was a registered slur.

German has Jude. It gave the world the Judensau (the pig Jew), Jud as a taunt, and the same word Judeprinted in black on a yellow star.

French has Juif, once a synonym for “usurer,” and the slurs youtre and youpin. Spanish has judiada—a “dirty trick.” Portuguese has judiar, which means to torment and mistreat. Italian keeps giudeo for the insult and ebreo for polite company. Dutch has jodenstreek, a swindle, and jodenfooi, a miser’s tip. In Russian, zhid is a slur in any context.

And then of course in Arabic it became a chant: Khaibar, Khaibar, ya Yahud! Jaish Muhammad sawfa ya‘ud!  “Khaybar, Khaybar, o Yehudi! The army of Muhammad will return!” Popularized during the First Intifada in the late 1980s by Ahmed Yassin, the founder of Hamas, the chant references the Battle of Khaybar of 628 C.E., which began after Muhammad marched with a large Muslim army and besieged Khaybar, an oasis in present-day Saudi Arabia that was home to an established Judean community.

But notice: the Arabs call us by our true name because we are their eternal enemies, while the West always calls us by a demeaning slur “Jew” because we have been their slaves since Rome. An enemy names you because he fears you. A master renames you because he owns you. And the West sees themselves as our masters. The church fathers took the honored name “Hebrews” for their own spiritual ancestors and left the living people the name “Jews,” and with it the charge of killing God. So the Christian West kept our heritage and gave us the slur of “Jew.”

“Kike,” “Sheeny,” and “Hymie” come from other places. Everything else I just listed is one word. It is Yehudah with pieces knocked off, turned into a weapon in ten languages.

The word “Jew” is about 500-years-old. My people are 4,000-years-old.

When we were sovereign and fighting Rome, we minted our own coins. The coins of the Great Revolt say “Shekel of Israel” and “Jerusalem the Holy.” Bar Kokhba’s coins say “Shim’on Prince of Israel” and “For the Freedom of Jerusalem.” Rome answered with its own coin: Iudaea Capta. Judea is captured. The free men wrote Yisrael. The conqueror wrote Iudaeus.

The people of Israel have three names, and each one has a job.

Ivri is the oldest. “Avram ha-Ivri,” Genesis 14:13. The root means to cross over. The Ivri is the one who crossed, the one who stands on the other side from the whole world. It is the name we use when we face foreigners: Joseph in Egypt, Moses saying “the G-d of the Ivrim” to Pharaoh, Jonah telling the sailors, Ivri anochi.

Yisrael is the name given to Jacob in Genesis 32, Yisra-El (the one who wrestles with God) after he fought and prevailed. It is the name of the people: Bnei Yisrael, Am Yisrael.

Yehudi is the name of the land and the kingdom. By the time of Esther, Mordechai is called ish Yehudi (“Judean man”), although he is from the tribe of Benjamin. It was already the name of the whole nation. And the same scroll has the first word for joining us: mityahadim, for those who joined the tribe and nation. It means to become a Yehudi, to join a people.

Yehudah itself as an adjective means “praise.” Our mother Leah named him so: “This time I will praise the Lord.” And his sign is the lion.

In May of 1948, the Zionist leaders had to name the new state. “Judea” was the most popular choice. “Zion” was proposed. So was Ever, from Ivri. “Judea” and “Zion” were dropped because those places were outside the partition lines. Nobody liked Ever. They chose “Israel” by a majority vote.

So I am a Yisraeli. But understand what happened to that word. Yisraeli now means two things: a child of Israel, and a citizen of the State of Israel. In 1972, and again in 2013, the Israeli Supreme Court refused to register “Israeli” as a nationality. That is why, in the State of Israel’s population registry, my nationality is Yehudi and my citizenship is Israeli.

That is why the diaspora cannot call itself Israeli. You are not citizens. But you can—and should—call yourselves Hebrews, Judeans, Israelites.

American Jews tried it in the nineteenth century. Hebrew Union College. The Union of American Hebrew Congregations. The Young Men’s Hebrew Association. They chose “Hebrew” because “Jew” was being spat at them. It ended as “Hebe.” In France they chose Israélite, and it became the polite word for a Jew who wanted to be a Frenchman of the Mosaic persuasion. 

Then came Pittsburgh, 1885: “We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community.” The German Reform rabbis had already voted in 1845 to take the return to Zion out of the prayers. And in English prayer books, Am Yisrael became “the Jewish people” and Eretz Yisrael became “the Holy Land.” These assimilated Jews erased themselves in their own translations. That is also why Western anti-Semites see it as legitimate to claim we are “fake” and have no rights over our land, and that Israel is not a real state and also declare Zionism as racism.

This linguistic surrender leads directly to what we can call the KJV English Syndrome. When an assimilated, English-speaking diaspora consumes its own history exclusively through translation, it loses the physical bedrock of the text. Through the lens of King James English, the Hebrew operating system is flattened into a portable, universalist religion. Specific geographical coordinates, native topography, and tribal laws become vague moral abstractions. Eretz Yisrael is sanitized into a generic “Holy Land.”

The assimilated Jew no longer reads the sovereign hardware of his ancestors; he reads a Western script. By adopting the language of the host culture to define their own identity, the diaspora unwittingly formatted their own hard drive. They learned to see themselves exactly as the English translation presented them: a stateless, religious community of the mind, completely detached from the physical dirt of Yehudah.

In the land of Israel—Eretz Israel—it was different from the start. The Yishuv built the Hebrew University, demanded Hebrew labor, and raised Hebrew battalions. They were Ivrim before they could be Yisraelim. Yonathan Ratosh and his Young Hebrews said in 1939: we are Hebrews, not Jews. Hillel Kook said it in 1944. They used the name to cut the nation off from the diaspora. The nation needed to be decolonized and we used the Hebrew language to do it.

We are the only people on earth whose name is avoided by those who are trying to be nice to us.

And today I am using it to call on the diaspora that remained behind out of free choice, a chosen exile, to shed the “Jew-ish” costume and to come back home and become Yehudi. And if you decide to stay in the diaspora, start calling yourselves Judeans or Hebrews, not Jews. Reclaim at least your name, your tie to the land you originate from. De-colonize your soul from the slurs given to us as a people and reclaim the honor you deserve as the people who defeated every empire in history, every erasure attempt, and every massacre.

Because only then when you stand in front of a hateful world, and even in front of other Jews who hate themselves, and say:

 “I am a Hebrew.” You are actually saying: “I am the truth.”

I understand the diaspora’s fear. In the diaspora the word “Jew” is all you have. Take away “Jew” and you have nothing left to stand on. I, as a Sabra, have the land. Take the word “Jew” from me and I am still standing in Yehudah, speaking the language of the Ivrim, holding the passport of Israel. 

I believe it is well past time for the diaspora to understand and embrace the fact that you are part of Am Yisrael: the people of Israel. Your DNA connects you directly to Eretz Yisrael. And only Yehudi—Judean—is the word that brings you back to the land of Yehudah, not the word “Jew.”

I call this the “Refraction Protocol.” It is the ability of the Hebrew people to take a “metadata tag” intended for humiliation—the modern “Mark of Cain”—and re-encode it as a symbol of sovereign defiance. They marked us with a yellow star, and we put it on a flag and on the wings of fighter jets. They forced a pointed “Jew hat” (Judenhut) on us as a sign of shame, and we kept our heads covered anyway, by our own choice, as a sign of awe before God, and we made it a symbol of national pride. They put animal tails on our heads, and we wove them into a shtreimel. Haman wanted us dead, and we eat his ears every year as a Purim delicacy.

So now you have to put the land back into the name. We Israelis already do so. And even when we say “I am a Jew” in English to foreigners, in our heads it translates to “Sovereign Israeli Yehudi.” Because this is all we know. We do not know exile.

Every other people does this, by the way, and the world obeys. The Inuit are no longer Eskimos. The Roma are no longer Gypsies. The Sámi are no longer Lapps. A sovereign people names itself.

The gentile culture cannot—must not—be allowed to define or name the Hebrews. You can delete the file, but you cannot format the drive. Gentiles deleted the name of Judea 2,000 years ago and renamed it “Syria Palaestina.” They then deleted one letter from our name in France 800 years ago to go from Yehudi to “Giu.” But the Hebrew hard drive is still here and it is alive, strong, and proud.

So no, I am not a Jew. I am a Yehudi from the land of Yehudah, I am an Ivri, the one who crossed over. I am a Yisraeli, a citizen of the only state my people ever had, given to me by G-d—Medinat ha-Yehudim. Yes, it is mine. By divine decree. Look into the mirror and say proudly Yehudi Anochi—I am Judean. Feel the shiver run down your spine and remember who you are. Say it 100 times a day, until you don’t need to say it anymore. Because you will become what you were born to be: a true child of Zion. Like me.  

Many years ago, I stopped praying for “next year in Jerusalem.” Because for me, it’s 30 minutes away on the train. 

And I will visit Jerusalem tomorrow. The day you begin to do that as well, you will understand what I mean.


Am Yisrael: Jews are Judeans

Start with the word itself. “Jew” is an English contraction of the Latin Iudaeus, the Greek Ioudaios, and, before both, the Hebrew Yehudi: a Judean, a person from Judea. The name was never a description of a religion as that concept is understood in the Western tradition. It was a statement of origin, and every empire that conquered, renamed or expelled the Judean people kept using it, because everyone knew where they came from. Where this essay speaks of the people, their history, and their homeland, it uses the older word.

For years, in arguably America’s most influential state, a debate raged over the treatment of Jews in drafts of California’s Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum (ESMC), which the state legislature required for the largest high school system in America. The first two drafts were rightly sent back to the drawing board because they were riddled with anti-Semitic content, often to the point of open expression of anti-Semitism. The final approved version excised the most flagrant segments, but there was significant reason to believe that school boards and districts would interpret and implement it on the premise that, among all ethnic minorities in the United States, Jewish Americans are unique beneficiaries of “white privilege.” 

That is what happened. Several districts contracted with the “Liberated Ethnic Studies” consortium, whose materials were built on that premise, and some of those arrangements drew legal challenges. After October 7, the problem became impossible to ignore. In October of 2025, Governor Gavin Newsom signed AB 715, which created an Office for Civil Rights to monitor anti-Semitism in California’s public schools, authorized an Anti-Semitism Prevention Coordinator and guidelines for teaching the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and set limits on how far ethnic studies curricula can carry anti-Zionist content into classrooms.

The flawed rationale for applying unique “privilege” to one of the most persecuted, per capita, and smallest ethnic minorities in history can be attributed, in large part, to the concept of “intersectionality,” the study of overlapping or intersecting social identities and the related systems of oppression, domination and discrimination. Because the creators of intersectionality are primarily academics on the political left, the framework has effectively placed Jews outside the “intersection.” The drafters of the ESMC (one of whom characterized the ADL as a “white supremacist organization”) continued the effort by many on the far left to whitewash Ashkenazic Jewry and to erase Mizrachi Jews and Jews of Color from the collective Judean experience and peoplehood. They did all this while championing efforts to destroy the nation-state of the Jewish people (a.k.a. Am Yisrael), through the BDS movement and otherwise, under the guise of a uniquely American or universalist pursuit of human rights.

This intersectional movement, in which perceived whiteness epitomizes unearned privilege, also mischaracterizes Ashkenazic Jewry, the historical whipping boy of Europe, and thereby positions these Jews as the ultimate bearers of privilege and, consequently, as among the ultimate oppressors.

Highlighted in the ESMC as a champion of this inverted version of racial liberation was Linda Sarsour, the outspoken anti-Israel Arab American activist and purveyor of anti-Semitism. It is both ironic and revealing that a white-presenting person was held up as a paragon of protest against white supremacism. In 2020, when black Americans filled the streets after the death of George Floyd, the libel that Jews are uniquely responsible for the racial injustices that cleave American society animated rhetoric and violence among many flag holders of the far left, effectively excluding most Jews from the multiethnic coalition that marched in solidarity with African Americans. After October 7, the same movement went further. “Zionists,” meaning the overwhelming majority of Jews, were declared unwelcome in progressive spaces outright.

The Jewish community, however, is a distinct ethnoreligious group with diverse membership, like other Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) communities, and it is regularly targeted by extremists for both its faith and its perceived racial difference. There is an undeniable double standard in a movement that presents Linda Sarsour as an oppressed person of color while collectively identifying Jews, or at least Ashkenazic Jews, as “white” and, even more incredibly, as bastions of whiteness. This position is not only regressive. It ignores thousands of years of Judean history, denies the experience of the Jewish people as a nation, and aids the campaign of those who ultimately seek to delegitimize Hebrew, or Judean, self-determination. Setting aside for the moment that “race” itself is an ideological construct, this characterization of Ashkenazic Jews ignores that every Middle Eastern and North African ethnicity (Arab, Amazigh, Copt, Judean, Assyrian, and others), as well as most Latino communities, includes members who, based on appearance alone, could “pass” for any number of races on the American racial identity chart.

Historically, many Arab and Jewish Americans arriving in the U.S. actively pursued identification with “whiteness” as a method of integration, despite facing legal and physical barriers for being perceived as non-white, ethnic, or racial “others.” Armenian Americans themselves pointed to the U.S. government’s granting of residency and citizenship to Ashkenazic Jews as grounds for their own naturalization (until 1952, whiteness was a factor in naturalization decisions).

The presiding judge in the 1909 case In re Halladjian, et al. ruled that, “[i]f the aboriginal people of Asia are excluded it is hard to find a loophole for the admission of Hebrews.” The judge’s statement that Jews represented an Asiatic presence in American society shows how widespread and uncontroversial that belief was at the turn of the twentieth century. It would defy credulity to believe that this view played no role in the anti-Semitic policies restricting Jewish homeownership and Jewish access to higher education, policies that persisted in the U.S. until the 1970s. Discriminatory policies targeting Jews in the U.S. also greeted refugees from the most recent white-supremacist slaughter in Europe, the Holocaust. One can only imagine the lasting impression a hotel advertisement reading “No Hebrews or tubercular guests received” made on a Judean refugee from the latest Cossack attempt to slaughter Jews in Russia.

The existence of Jews of Color (JOC), Jews (Ashkenazic, Sephardi, or otherwise) whose appearance or heritage combines with that of ethnic groups not stereotypically associated with American Jews, is also regularly used to collectively whitewash, or Europeanize, the Ashkenazic component of American Jewish identity. This ignores the ubiquitous presence of Middle Eastern-presenting Ashkenazic Jews (Sacha Baron Cohen, an Ashkenazi Jew, earned a Golden Globe nomination playing Eli Cohen, the Mizrachi spy who penetrated the highest levels of the Syrian defense establishment for almost five years) as well as European-presenting Mizrachi Jews. The unique struggles and experiences of African, Latino, Asian, and Mizrachi Jews are weaponized to deny the Middle Eastern heritage and identity of Ashkenazim in America, and thereby to undermine Judean peoplehood globally. Jews of Color may be uniquely positioned in the fight against colorism and racism, for equality in America and against anti-Semitism, but that fight must be waged with the same sensitivity to the complexities of Ashkenazic identity and experience that is demanded of others with regard to Jewish identity and experience.

The issue of Jewish “whiteness” (Ashkenormativity), and of race in America generally, must be tackled with the intention of strengthening the American Jewish community as an inseparable part of the Judean people and its history. Any attempt to whitewash Jewishness as merely a religion or a cute culture, or to characterize Ashkenazic Jews as “Europeans with a Jewish religion,” rather than as the vessel of an enduring ancient civilization with an unbroken chain of language, culture, and spirituality, is an attempt to uproot the people of Israel (Am Yisrael) from their ancestral inheritance and their rights as a nation. As the name Am Yisrael says, the Jews are a people, not happenstance coreligionists.

So, who are American Jews?

Jewish identity is complex in the context of contemporary identity politics only because many remain adamant about defining Jewishness through the prism of America’s relatively short history. Judeans, however, are an ancient people. They are the only nation in history to have experienced multiple exiles, genocides, and enslavements yet maintained for millennia a Diaspora of communities that preserved most of their culture, language, and religion. It is this assortment of symbols, idiosyncrasies, customs, words, stories, and beliefs that has come to be described as Judaism. Religion can appropriately describe and explain the origin of many of these customs and beliefs, but Judean peoplehood rests on far more than religion or faith.

Ashkenazic culture, embodied by the Yiddish language, expresses a direct link to the first Judeans taken to southern Europe as slaves. Yiddish, developed as a language of internal communication, rests on a Germanic base, but it carries a deep Hebrew and Aramaic layer (including Aramaic terms that entered Judean speech after the Babylonian exile), an early Romance layer from the Judean communities of Italy and France, and later Slavic additions. Its reliance on Hebrew and Aramaic for the objects and ideas of greatest cultural importance, and for key features of expression and idiom, demonstrates that Ashkenazi Jews inherited the unbroken chain of Hebrew civilization that was brought to Europe (and North Africa) in chains. The impact of this ancient Levantine culture was so deeply felt in Ashkenazic life that as late as the thirteenth century there existed commentary describing a contemporary shift from the Levantine pronunciation of Hebrew to what became the Ashkenazic standard. The genetic evidence, laid out in this magazine’s companion piece on Judean DNA, tells the same story.

Judean identity is based on more than 3,300 years of history. It is not defined by the American experience. It was during the Judean people’s first millennia that the common features of their peoplehood, which all Jews share with all other Jews regardless of where their ancestors spent the Diaspora, were developed. This peoplehood took shape in the Judean people’s indigenous homeland, the land of Israel, in Judea. That is where their national language, Hebrew, and their tribal faith, Judaism, developed. That is where the principal aspects of their tribal culture developed, and, as for all indigenous tribal peoples, that culture revolves around holidays, sacred events, and sites located in, and only in, the land of Israel.

After the Judean people developed their unique tribal faith and peoplehood in the land of Israel, their millennia-long “scattering among the nations,” the Diaspora, began as a result of Roman imperialism in the year 70 C.E. A large part of the Judean population was massacred, enslaved, or exiled. In Judea, approximately 25% of the Jewish population was exterminated and 10% enslaved. Many Judeans were taken as slaves to Rome and other parts of the Roman Empire in Europe. Many others fled the Roman massacres and enslavement to Mesopotamia (modern-day Iraq) and to lands all around the Mediterranean, in what is today southeastern Spain, southern France, southern Italy, Greece, Cyprus, and Turkey. 

Judeans are an ancient people. They are the only nation in history to have experienced multiple exiles, genocides, and enslavements yet maintained for millennia a Diaspora of communities that preserved most of their culture, language, and religion.

Throughout the decades and centuries that followed, Jews moved north, to what is today northern France, Belgium, Holland, Germany, Austria, Bulgaria, and Bosnia, and into North Africa, to what is today Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, and Morocco. By around 300 C.E., approximately three million Jews were living in most parts of the Roman Empire, except what is today Britain. A million lived west of Greece, with the majority settled throughout Asia Minor and east to the Caspian Sea and the Persian Gulf. By then, a sizable number of Jews were living in what centuries later would become Germany.

A common feature of the next 1,600 years, when the Jews were always stateless and therefore, as a community, defenseless, was migration. Because Jews were regularly attacked, banished, or forced to submit to discriminatory and oppressive laws, the “wandering Jew” became a necessary feature of the Diaspora. From the ninth-century decrees of the Abbasid caliph al-Mutawakkil, which ordered Jews to wear yellow patches to set them apart from the Muslim majority, to the infamous Venetian ghetto of the sixteenth century, through the Nazi-created ghettos of Poland, being “othered” and subjected to cyclical and often intense persecution was the ominous cloud that hovered over the Judean Diaspora.

In Europe, the ethnic “otherness” of Jews and Roma (a non-European people of South Asian origin) ultimately became a universal object of white-supremacist xenophobia and prejudice. As peoples in Diaspora, both groups were invariably influenced, by force and by choice, by their surroundings, as all Diaspora communities are. Just as Ashkenazi Jews are targeted today by many self-described progressives because many of them can “pass” for their host population, European racial anti-Semitism developed its specific hatred of Jews on the inverse basis. What began with the Spanish Inquisition’s claim that Jewish forced converts to Catholicism carried “impure blood” reached its zenith in Nazi ideology. Regardless of their appearance, Ashkenazi Jews were defined as mongrel Israelites and therefore the greatest threat to the so-called white race. Because Jews in Europe, Ashkenazic or Sephardic, included individuals who could present as “white,” “Asiatic,” or “black” according to the stereotypes, they were collectively branded a shape-shifting black contamination.

“The Jew is a bastard”—Nazi chart depicting the mixed Asiatic and African ancestry of Ashkenazic Jewry. (Credit: United States Holocaust Memorial Museum)

White supremacists have always used and perverted the diversity of appearance within Ashkenazic Jewry to associate Jews collectively with blackness and the supposed race-mixing they hate, and to expose Jews to the social wrath that association might incur. Many on the opposite end of the political spectrum today pervert that same diversity to associate Ashkenazic Jewry with whiteness, and to expose Jews to the social wrath that association incurs in far-left circles. Both approaches are steeped in anti-Semitic paternalism and conspiracy-theorizing. Both seek to rob Jews of the agency to define themselves, while associating every Judean effort at self-determination, whether as returned Levantines sovereign in their Middle Eastern homeland or as Middle Eastern Americans in the U.S., with duplicity and conspiracies to dominate and control others.

October 7 + the “Go Back to Poland” Libel

When this essay was first published, its argument could still be dismissed as an academic quarrel over a California curriculum. October 7, 2023, ended that. Within hours of Hamas’s massacre of some 1,200 people, most of them civilians, and its abduction of at least 251 more, the theory described above was put to work as a justification. The murdered, raped, and kidnapped were recast as “settlers” and “colonizers,” and the slaughter was justified as “decolonization.” Protesters in Western cities told Israelis to “go back to Poland,” as though a people whose very name means Judean, and who prayed toward Jerusalem in Hebrew for two thousand years of exile, were European interlopers in Judea.

That is where the “white Jew” slander was always headed. If Jews are white Europeans, then Israel is a European colony, and every Israeli—including those from the roughly 60% of Israelis whose families spent over a millennia in the Jewish Diaspora in lands Arabs conquered in the seventh and eighth century—is a foreigner whose murder can be called resistance. The racial reclassification of Ashkenazic Judeans was never a harmless error of American identity politics. It was the intellectual groundwork for denying an indigenous people the right to live in their homeland, and on October 7 people were murdered under this banner.

Through most of the twentieth century, Jews of every appearance were restricted in where they could buy homes or attend school as “members of the Hebrew race.” That does not change the fact that African and Caribbean American Jews also endured discrimination for belonging to both the “Hebrew” and “Negro” races. This dichotomy in navigating American racism, between Jews and black Americans collectively and within the Jewish community itself, is a fact of Jewish communal life. It presents Jews with a question. Should they double down, become entrenched in their traumas, and allow the shadows of whiteness and blackness to further divide the Judean people?

No. Racial justice must address every community according to the complexities of its experience. As Jews, with a literal mandate from the Torah to pursue justice and given their own history of discrimination and persecution in the U.S., they have an obligation to acknowledge, address, and help redress the plainly different experiences of oppression and racism that African Americans, Caribbean Americans, Native Americans and other communities endured in North America. Jews can and should do this while affording themselves the same sensitivity they must extend to others. And they should demand the same treatment from others, particularly from those who claim to care about racial justice: to approach the Judean people according to the complexities of their experience, not only in America but over millennia in Arab-controlled and European-controlled lands, where being a Jew almost always marked a person as a second-class subject and often marked them for death.

A Unified Identity Matters. And It’s Judean.

The path forward should be clear. Rather than allowing either the tiki-torch carriers of the far right or those on the far left who abuse anti-racism as a cover for their own anti-Semitism to define the experience of some or all members of the Jewish community, it is the Judean people’s responsibility to reclaim this discourse, since they will reap the consequences of its outcome. Judeans should decolonize and re-indigenize both their rhetoric and their minds. They should understand that identity matters, and that how they identify themselves, matters.

Judeans must take pride in their identity. That pride requires an understanding that whether they are African, Ashkenazic, Mizrachi, or Sephardic, their histories are inexorably linked. Those links come from a common heritage, culture, and faith carried across thousands of years of perseverance under persecution by the empires of the world. That is their collective history and their collective bond. Judeans must reject the idea that because of their diversity, itself a product of the Diaspora, there are “white” (meaning European) Jews in America.

The reality is that there is no non-European ethnic minority in America without members who can present or pass as white. It is also true that in a highly racialized America, numerous ethnic minorities could and did benefit from closer association with “whiteness.” That is why there were nearly a dozen cases in the first half of the twentieth century in which Arabs in America sued to be classified as “white.” None of that means Judeans should accept being defined by others or being the only MENA ethnic minority characterized in twenty-first-century America as “white.”

Washington has since conceded the underlying point. In March of 2024, the Office of Management and Budget revised the federal race and ethnicity standards to create a separate Middle Eastern or North African category, ending the decades-old practice of counting people from the region as “white.” The examples OMB lists for the new category include Israelis. The federal government now recognizes that people from the Levant are not Europeans. The ideologues who write ethnic studies curricula have yet to catch up.

The bottom line is that the “white race” is a fiction created by the same category of people who used it to oppress and persecute Jews for centuries. That alone is reason for Judeans in America to reject this characterization of their identity. How some European racists decided to label people a few hundred years ago should have no bearing on Judean identity, an identity that predates European race pseudo-science by roughly three millennia.

Judeans should decolonize and re-indigenize both their rhetoric and their minds. They should understand that identity matters, and that how they identify themselves, matters.

Natan Sharansky once said: “There is no power in the world that can stand against us [Jews] when we feel a part of our history, part of our people, and part of this historic struggle.” The late Rabbi Jonathan Sacks (zt”l) called Pesach “the festival of Jewish identity. It is the night on which we tell our children who they are.” If Judeans stand united in an identity grounded in 3,300 years of history, in the shared story of deliverance from Egyptian bondage and in the national covenant formed at Mount Sinai, they will also understand, as Sharansky urges, the importance of refusing to be defined in any way by the categories of those who oppressed them for millennia, whether European or Arab.

As for many other ethnic groups, America has been a mixed bag for the Judean people. It meant escape from egregious persecution in eighteenth- to twentieth-century Europe, and later from Iran and many Arab dictatorships. It was also, particularly in the nineteenth century, a refuge with its own litany of limitations and violent threats, threats that continue to spill Judean blood today. Like other ethnic minorities in the U.S. that are neither African American nor Native American, Judeans are familiar with serving as a buffer community, granted certain relative privileges in exchange for being scapegoated when things go wrong.

For the U.S. to live up to its founding principles of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, Judeans and all people of good conscience should come together to strengthen and uplift the most disadvantaged communities in the nation. That must be done without capitulating to anti-Semitism and anti-Semitic tropes, whether that anti-Semitism is rooted in white supremacy, in black supremacy of the Nation of Islam variety, or in any other form or justification, including anti-Semitism disguised as anti-Zionism. Judeans in America must be allowed a seat at the table of racial justice without having to negate or degrade their authentic selves, and that includes their identity as a Middle Eastern, specifically Levantine Hebrew, tribal people from Judea, and as a diverse people with members who also belong to the African, Latino, Native, and Asian American communities.

The next time purportedly progressive thinkers create a curriculum meant to foster a better understanding of ethnicity, race, or bigotry, they need to recognize that Judeans collectively trace their origins to the Middle East, and that the Judean relationship to whiteness and white supremacy is comparable to that of other Middle Eastern Americans. No Judeans, whether Ashkenazim, Sephardim, or Mizrachim, should be uniquely stigmatized, among all ethnic minorities in America, as privileged “white people” or Europeans. Anyone aware of twenty-first-century progressive politics knows that in the context of American history, “white” is synonymous with “European,” which is synonymous with more than 500 years of European colonialism and oppression of non-Europeans. And anyone familiar with Judean history knows precisely the price the Judeans paid in Europe for not being “white.”

Malcolm X famously said of the African American experience, “We didn’t land on Plymouth Rock. Plymouth Rock landed on us.” The Judeans, Ashkenazim and Sephardim alike, did not land in Europe. Europe landed on them, over and over again. From the time Judeans were brought to Rome in chains, through millennia of blood libels, the Spanish Inquisition, countless pogroms and the Holocaust, in which six million Jews, most of them Ashkenazim, were slaughtered in less than five years, Europe made it crystal clear to the Judean people that they were never European, never “white,” and certainly never the beneficiaries of 500 years of colonialism and conquest. On October 7, the people who call Judeans “white Europeans” showed what that label is for—to justify our murder and their dreams of our expulsion. To treat Judeans as European is anti-Semitic because it erases the Judean collective experience and history. It erases the Judean people’s very identity. No truly progressive person should engage in or tolerate that erasure, and no proud Judean should stand for it. Not for a second.


I Thought I Knew What it Meant to Be Jewish

I am a proud Zionist American Jew. For most of my life, I never saw a contradiction among those three words. I still don’t. But since October 7, I have thought much more deeply about what the word Jew actually means.

I am a second-generation Holocaust survivor, a “2G.” My grandfather, Ignacy Chiger, survived the Holocaust with my grandmother, Paulina, my mother, Krystyna, and her little brother, Paweł. When the Nazis liquidated the Lwów ghetto, my family escaped by digging their way into the city’s sewer system.

They remained underground for 14 months. My mother was seven years old when she entered the sewer. Their crime was not something they had done. It was what they were… Jews.

I grew up with that history. I have spent many years of my adult life preserving it. I helped bring my grandfather’s memoir to a new generation. I speak about my family’s survival because I believe memory without responsibility is just nostalgia.

So, I thought I understood Jewish identity. Then came October 7… and something changed.

I Felt It in My Bones

I watched Israelis I had never met murdered, kidnapped, and brutalized… and my reaction surprised even me.

This was happening thousands of miles away. But it did not feel far away. It felt very personal.

I didn’t need someone to explain the connection to me… I felt it in my bones.

Then I watched what happened next.

Before Israel had even buried its dead, demonstrations began. On college campuses, in the streets, and across social media, the massacre itself seemed almost immediately to disappear into an argument about Israel. Soon Israel was no longer simply a country whose government or policies could be criticized. It was colonialist… “Oppressor…” “Apartheid…” “Genocidal…” “Illegitimate.”

And I began asking myself two questions. Why does this tiny country generate such extraordinary obsession? And why do I care so deeply about what happens to people thousands of miles away whom I have never met?

The answer led me back thousands of years: Am Yisrael—or simply Am. The People of Israel.

Not simply the followers of Judaism, but the People of Israel.

We Are a People

One of the mistakes we have made in America is allowing Judaism to be squeezed into the Western definition of religion. Judaism certainly is a religion. But Jews are also a people.

Long before anyone used words like ethnicity or nationality, Jews understood themselves as a people with a common origin, history, civilization, language, traditions, collective memory, and ancestral homeland. We were dispersed, but we did not forget where we came from. We prayed facing Jerusalem. At Passover, wherever we were in the world, we told the same story. Think about what happens at the Seder table. Jews in New York, Jerusalem, Haifa, Tel Aviv, Toronto, Paris, London, Buenos Aires, and thousands of other places tell the story of the Exodus at essentially the same moment.

As children, we hear it. As adults, we tell it. Then our children tell it.

For one night, Jews scattered throughout the world become almost one united soul, remembering the same journey from slavery to freedom. And at the end we say words Jews said centuries before the creation of the modern State of Israel: “Next year in Jerusalem.”

Why Jerusalem? Because Israel did not suddenly become important to Jews in 1948. The State of Israel is modern. The Jewish connection to the Land of Israel is ancient.

Modern genetics has added another fascinating piece to that story. Studies of many geographically separated Jewish populations have found substantial shared Middle Eastern ancestry. But I don’t need a DNA test to tell me who I am. Neither did my grandfather. Neither does my mother.

Our peoplehood is written not only in DNA, but in history, language, ritual, memory, civilization, and family. The thread survived because generation after generation refused to let it break.

My Mother Didn’t Get to Choose

There is an irony here that I cannot escape. My mother did not get to decide whether she was Jewish. The Nazis decided that for her. They did not ask whether seven-year-old Krystyna Chiger believed in God, or how often her parents attended synagogue. They did not ask whether she considered herself culturally Jewish, religiously Jewish, or secular. She was a Jew. That was enough.

For 14 months she lived beneath the streets of Lwów because the society above had decided that a Jewish child had no right to live. And yet today Jews are sometimes told that Jewishness is merely a religion, while the national dimension of Jewish identity is somehow artificial. That would have been news to the people who spent centuries treating us as a people.

It certainly would have been news to my family.

The New Bargain

Today the bargain offered to Jews is very different. You can be Jewish, celebrate the holidays, eat the food, tell stories about your grandparents, and mourn the Holocaust.

Just don’t be too Jewish. Separate yourself from Israel. Renounce Zionism. Prove that you are one of the “good” Jews.

In other words, you may retain the Jewish identity others are comfortable with, provided you surrender the part they are not.

Well… I have news for you. I won’t make that bargain.

That doesn’t mean Israel is beyond criticism. Of course it isn’t. I don’t agree with every Israeli government or every Israeli policy any more than I agree with every American government or every American policy. Family doesn’t require blindness. It requires belonging. And after October 7, I understood that belonging differently.

There is an ancient Jewish principle:

Kol Yisrael arevim zeh bazeh—“All Jews are responsible for one another.”

For me, those words no longer feel theoretical.

We Prepared Our Children for Everything Except This

October 7 also forced me to confront an uncomfortable question about American Jewry.

What did we teach our children?

Few communities in America have believed in education more passionately than American Jews. We prepared our children for the SATs, we hired tutors, we worried about AP courses, we obsessed over college applications, we celebrated the acceptance letter from the prestigious university, and Jewish families and philanthropists poured enormous sums into many of those same institutions.

Long before anyone used words like ethnicity or nationality, Jews understood themselves as a people with a common origin, history, civilization, language, traditions, collective memory, and ancestral homeland. We were dispersed, but we did not forget where we came from. We prayed facing Jerusalem.

We didn’t just ask for a seat at the table… we helped build that table.

But while preparing our children to get into college, did we prepare them for what they might encounter when they arrived?

Sure… we prepared them academically, and professionally.

Did we prepare them Jewishly?

A young Jew can arrive at an elite university knowing calculus, chemistry, and economics and still be unable to answer some of the most basic questions about his or her own people. Who are the Jews? Where did we come from? Why Jerusalem? What is Zionism? Why did Jews pray toward this particular land for thousands of years? Why did Hebrew survive? Why did Jews scattered across Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East continue thinking of themselves as one people? And what happens when a confident classmate tells that Jewish student that Jews are simply European colonizers who stole somebody else’s country?

Too often, we have sent our children into that conversation unprepared. Worse, some were never given the confidence to believe they had the right to answer. That isn’t their failure.

It’s ours.

Someone Will Give Them an Identity

Human beings need to belong. We need meaning, community, direction, recognition. We need to feel connected to something larger than ourselves. And if we don’t give our children a meaningful identity, someone else will. Political movements understand this extremely well. They can offer a group, an identity, a mission, an explanation.

And an enemy.

That is why I have become interested in something larger than the anti-Israel slogans we hear today.

For one part of the Western activist movement, Palestine has become woven into a much broader struggle against capitalism, colonialism, traditional institutions, the nation-state, and the West itself. Once politics becomes identity, contradiction becomes easier to overlook. Progressive activists who passionately champion women’s rights, gay rights, religious freedom, and individual liberty can find themselves marching alongside Islamist movements whose vision of society may reject those very principles. They don’t necessarily agree about the world they want to build. Sometimes it is enough to agree about whom they oppose. And when what you are against becomes more important than what you are for, ideological consistency becomes less important.

Israel has become a remarkably useful enemy.

But Jews create a problem for a simple oppressor-versus-oppressed worldview. We don’t fit neatly into it. We are supposedly colonizers, yet our civilization arose in the land we are accused of colonizing. We are described as foreign to the Middle East, yet Jewish history in the Land of Israel predates Christianity and Islam. We are portrayed as representatives of white European power, while millions of Israeli Jews descend from Jewish communities of the Middle East and North Africa. And within living memory, Jews possessed neither a country nor an army nor sovereign power.

My mother is living evidence of what that powerlessness looked like.

The Great Change in Jewish History

My grandparents had nowhere to go.

No Jewish army was coming for them. No Jewish government was negotiating for them. No country in the world existed whose fundamental purpose included providing a refuge for Jews.

Think about how extraordinary that is compared with today.

For much of Jewish history, our vulnerability came partly from the fact that we had no country, no army, and no sovereign power.

Today we have the State of Israel. A strong State of Israel.

And perhaps we need to recognize something else. Some people don’t hate us because we’re weak. They hate us because we’re strong. That is an entirely different Jewish problem.

And frankly, I prefer it.

My mother spent 14 months hiding beneath the ground because Jews were powerless. I will never apologize because her children and grandchildren live in a world in which Jews are not.

But Strength Is Not Enough

Here is where I think my generation has another responsibility.

I don’t want our children to build their Jewish identity around anti-Semitism. I don’t want the Holocaust to be the strongest reason my grandchildren know they are Jewish. There is something terribly inadequate about teaching young Jews that Jewish history is essentially the story of people trying to kill us. We are not a “people” because people hate us.

People hate us because we stubbornly remained a “people.”

If we don’t give our children a meaningful identity, someone else will.

That distinction matters.

Our inheritance is not merely Auschwitz. It is Jerusalem. It is Hebrew. It is Torah and Talmud. It is argument and Chavrutah. It is a civilization that teaches two people to sit across from one another, disagree, challenge each other’s assumptions, and emerge sharper rather than enemies.

It is music, humor, family, food, literature, learning, questioning, responsibility… Israel… Life.

Am Yisrael chai doesn’t mean simply that the Jewish people survived. It means the Jewish people live.

I Want Confident Jews

My mother learned at seven years old that the world considered her a Jew. My generation learned what could happen when Jews were powerless. Our children need to learn something different. They need to learn what it means to be Jewish when we are no longer powerless. 

They should know the Holocaust. They must know it.

But they also need to know how Jews lived, not merely how Jews died. They need enough Jewish knowledge to walk onto a college campus without requiring someone else to explain their own history to them. They should be able to encounter criticism of Israel without feeling that their identity is collapsing. They should be capable of saying, “Israel did something wrong,” without concluding, “Israel therefore has no right to exist.” They should know enough to distinguish criticism from delegitimization.

They should be able to argue, question, challenge, defend, and sometimes change their minds. In other words, I don’t want to see frightened Jewish children with knocking knees.

I want confident Jews.

My Grandparents Were Jews. My Grandchildren Must Be Jews.

There is something else I have come to believe, and perhaps I feel it more strongly because I am a 2G.

I am enormously proud that my grandparents were Jews. I am proud of the courage with which they survived as Jews. I have devoted a significant part of my life to preserving their story. Their experience has shaped who I am. But I have come to believe that something else matters even more.

It is more important to me that my grandchildren are raised Jewish than that my grandparents were Jews.

That may sound strange coming from someone who spends so much time looking backward. But Jewish continuity cannot only look backward. If our greatest expression of Jewish identity is remembering our grandparents, eventually there will be no Jewish grandchildren left to remember them.

That is the difference between memory and continuity.

We have become extraordinarily good at teaching young Jews to look backward. We take them to Holocaust museums. We teach them about Auschwitz. We tell them what happened when the world abandoned the Jews. All of that is essential.

But then what?

My grandparents’ Jewishness is history. My grandchildren’s Jewishness is the future.

The Nazis tried to end the Jewish story by murdering Jewish children. Our answer cannot simply be to remember the children they murdered. Our answer must also be to raise Jewish children… not out of fear, or out of guilt, and certainly not because they owe something to the dead.

I want my grandchildren raised Jewish because there is something magnificent to inherit. I want them to experience a Passover Seder and understand that they are not reenacting someone else’s ancient story.

It is their story.

I want them to hear Hebrew and recognize it as the language their people carried across centuries. I want them to understand why Jerusalem matters before someone else tells them why it shouldn’t. I want them to argue around a table, ask uncomfortable questions, challenge authority, and discover that questioning is not a rejection of Judaism. It is one of Judaism’s oldest traditions. I want them to know Israel not merely as a country that appears in the news when there is a war, but as part of their inheritance. Most of all, I want them to experience Judaism as something joyful enough, meaningful enough, and important enough that someday they will want to hand it to their own children.

That is Jewish confidence.

Jews create a problem for a simple oppressor-versus-oppressed worldview. We don’t fit neatly into it. We are supposedly colonizers, yet our civilization arose in the land we are accused of colonizing. We are described as foreign to the Middle East, yet Jewish history in the Land of Israel predates Christianity and Islam.

What You Teach the Kids is What the Future Is

Maybe this means American Jews need to rethink Jewish education. Maybe a serious Israel experience before college should become as normal in Jewish families as SAT preparation. Maybe we should invest as passionately in preparing our children for Jewish life as we do in preparing them for professional life. And maybe before asking every Jewish 17-year-old, “Where are you going to college?” we should also ask: “What do you know about the people you’re taking with you?”

Because what you teach the kids is what the future is. Not what you tell them once, and not what you put on a bumper sticker.

It’s what you teach them… what they live… what they know… what they love, and what people they belong to.

The Thread

My grandfather, Ignacy, died six months after completing the memoir of his family’s survival. Decades later, I helped bring his words into English. My mother survived to tell her own story.

I inherited their story.

And now I understand my responsibility differently.

My grandparents’ responsibility was to survive.

My mother’s responsibility was to remember.

Mine is to transmit.

And our children’s responsibility will be to decide whether they transmit it again.

That is the thread.

October 7 did not make me Jewish. It reminded me what being Jewish means.

I am an American.

I am a Zionist.

I am a Jew.

I am the grandson of Ignacy and Paulina Chiger. I am the son of Krystyna Chiger.

But increasingly, I understand that the most important Jewish description of me may not concern the generations that came before me. It may be the generations that come after.

I want to be the grandfather of Jewish grandchildren.

Because ultimately, the measure of Jewish survival is not only how faithfully we remember the Jews who came before us. It is whether there are Jews who come after us. We came from somewhere… we remember where… we know who we are. And now we have to make certain our children and grandchildren know it too.

Am Yisrael.

One people. One land. One future.

Am Yisrael chai.


Judean Roots, Judean Fruit

“‘…And I will give unto thee, and to thy seed after thee, the land of thy sojournings, all the land of Canaan, for an everlasting possession; and I will be their God.’”
Genesis 17:8 

“When does one first begin to remember?” begins Winston Churchill’s majestic autobiography, My Early Life. The Jewish people have consistently done so ever since Mosheh told them in D’varim 31:19 to “Now therefore write ye this song [the Torah] for you, and teach thou it the children of Israel; put it in their mouths, that this song may be a witness for Me against the children of Israel.” This Mr. Churchill, a dear and life-long friend of the Jews, knew.

Despite colonization, massacre, dispersion, and genocide, the Jews reside today as then in their ancient home, speaking their ancient language, and clinging with heroism and righteousness to their ancient religion. Nearly three and a half millennia have turned to dust since signs and wonders brought them to a land flowing with destiny. The roots planted in the day of Yehoshua’s sword, though neglected for a time, now bloom as the fruits of their fealty.

The tongue which the One who shaped us in the womb used to spread the stars to the farthest ends of space is spoken again throughout the cities of Yehudah. As said Yir’miyahu long before fine, fluted columns graced Hellas, in the streets of Yerushalayim are heard the voices of gladness and joy, the voices of bridegroom and bride. Familiar in their mouths and freshly remembered, the strains of David’s lyre sweeten the air like the scent of olive groves. The eagles’ wings rest and their nests are warmed and full.

The Jewish people are a family, a nation, a land, a book, a story on which the sun never and will never set. For they fear no evil.

Hebrew alphabetic exercise. Iron Age I, c. 12th century B.C.E. Iz’bet Sar’tah. Pottery. 16 x 9 cm. IAA: 1980-1. (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
“Isaiah seal,” c. 8th century B.C.E. Clay impression. (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
Jug with Hebrew inscription (“[Belonging] to Yehumal”). Iron Age II, c. 8th–7th century B.C.E. Chev’ron area. Pottery. 21 x 13 cm. IAA: 1975-242. (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
Hebrew letter. Iron Age II, 7th–6th century B.C.E. Arad. Ink on pottery. 6.2 x 4.3 cm. IAA: 1967-669. (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
Graffito with temple vessels. Herodian period, 1st century B.C.E. Jewish Quarter, Jerusalem. Plaster. 32 x 32 cm. IAA: 1982-1055. (Yoram Lehmann / Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
Oil lamp with original wick. 1st century B.C.E.–1st century C.E. Qumran cave, Judean Desert. Pottery. 4.3 x 10 cm. 97.74(147); IAA: 346303-פ.  (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
Section from the Great Psalms Scroll (11Q5). c. 30–50 C.E. Qumran Cave 11, Judean Desert. Parchment. (Shai Halevi and Leon Levy / Dead Sea Scrolls Digital Library)
Bronze p’rutah of the First Jewish Revolt. April 67–March 68 C.E. Jerusalem. Bronze. Obverse: Amphora with broad rim and two handles; Shenat sh’tayim (“Year 2”). Reverse: Vine leaf on branch; Cherut Tziyon (“[For the] freedom of Zion”). Diameter: 17 mm. Private collection. (Ben Poser / White Rose Magazine)
Letter in Greek from the archive of the lady Babatha. c. 96–134 C.E. Cave of Letters, Judean Desert. Papyrus. (Israel Museum, Jerusalem / Alamy Stock)
Menorah. 6th century C.E. Ein Gedi synagogue. Bronze. 21.5 x 14 cm. IAA: 1970-612. (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)
Incantation bowl with Hebrew script. c. 1450 C.E. Land of Israel. Ink on pottery. Glass lantern slide. c. 1900. LS2457-A. Collection of David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
Map of the Kingdoms of Judah and Israel. Histoire universelle depuis le commencement du monde jusqu’à présent, traduite de l’anglois. Bd. 3 (Amsterdam: Arkstée et Merkus, 1771), p. 1. (Alamy Stock)

“‘…Thus saith the Lord GOD: Behold, I will take the children of Israel from among the nations, whither they are gone, and will gather them on every side, and bring them into their own land… I will make a covenant of peace with them—it shall be an everlasting covenant with them; and I will establish them, and multiply them, and will set My sanctuary in the midst of them for ever.’”
Ezekiel 37:21, 26 

Félix Adrien Bonfils (1831–1885). Jewish men in Jerusalem. c. 1870. Glass lantern slide. LS421. Collection of David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). Torah scroll. 1898. Glass lantern slide. LS809. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
Jews at the Western Wall. c. 1900. Glass lantern slide. LS1440. Collection of David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
Félix Adrien Bonfils (1831–1885). “Jerusalem Jew.” c. 1870. Glass lantern slide. LS3815. Collection of David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
Yemenite Jewish boy learning to read. Jerusalem. c. 1900. Glass lantern slide. LS3866. Collection of David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). Southern view of the Mount of Olives. March 23, 1902. Glass lantern slide. LS298. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). View of the Western Wall from the roof of a synagogue. April 4, 1902. Glass lantern slide. LS327. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). Jewish women and children. T’ver’yah. c. April 1907. Glass lantern slide. LS3924. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). Jewish settlement at Rosh Pinah. Upper Galilee. April 16, 1907. Glass lantern slide. LS1284. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
David Gordon Lyon (1852–1935). Jewish school in Metulah. Northern Israel. April 18, 1907. LS1303. Collection of David Gordon Lyon. (Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East)
Liselotte Grschebina (1908–1994). Bukharan girl, Jerusalem. 1937. Gelatin silver print. 22.5 × 16.8 cm. B01.0244(0119). (Israel Museum, Jerusalem)

“The flowers appear on the earth;
The time of singing is come,
And the voice of the turtle is heard in our land.…
Awake, O north wind;
And come, thou south;
Blow upon my garden,
That the spices thereof may flow out.
Let my beloved come into his garden,
And eat his precious fruits.”
Song of Songs 2:12, 4:16 

Flowers glow by the Kineret. July 6, 2010. (Ben Poser)
Prayer before the dawn. Metzadah. July 13, 2010. (Ben Poser)
“Welcome to the Jewish Quarter.” Jerusalem. July 14, 2010. (Ben Poser)
Metzadah, over which the sun shall never fall. July 14, 2012. (Ben Poser)

“Should you have been banished to the very sky’s end, your God will gather you again even from there….”
Deuteronomy 30:4


Judeans: Faith + Ethnicity

It is often ignored that Jerusalem is also the national ethnic center of the Jewish people. Whereas Christianity and Islam’s attachments to Jerusalem are only religious, there is a dual Jewish religious and national-ethnic attachment to the city. Jerusalem has been the national capital of the Jewish people for 3,000 years and continues to serve as the capital of the modern State of Israel.

Membership Required

You must be a subscriber to access this content

Already a member? Log in here

Judean Ethnicity: The DNA Evidence

Genetics has proven that modern Jewish populations carry their Israelite ancestors’ ancient Middle Eastern DNA.

Membership Required

You must be a subscriber to access this content

Already a member? Log in here

Judean Assimilation Never Works

“What is needed is the leaven—what is needed is the seed of fire. The heritage of Israel is beating in the pulses of millions; it lives in their veins as a power without understanding, like the morning exultation of herds; it is the inborn half of memory, moving as in a dream among writings on the walls, which it sees dimly but cannot divide into speech.… Who says that the history and literature of our race are dead? Are they not as living as the history and literature of Greece and Rome…? These were an inheritance dug from the tomb. Ours is an inheritance that has never ceased to quiver in millions of human frames.” 

—Mordecai
George Eliot, Daniel Deronda (1876)

An historical leitmotif as eternal as human folly itself is that when Jews pretend not to be Jews, the only long-term outcome is catastrophe.

This is hardly to say that it is forbidden for Jews to learn the languages, use the technology, and obey the secular laws of the nations in which they are resident. Instead, it is answering “I am a Greek”—or “I am a comrade like you”—when asked “Are you a Jew?” which assures future disaster.

Acculturation vs. Assimilation

Throughout history, Jews have been faced with the fundamental human conundrum of how to live in a world in which they are perennial strangers. After all, obstinate, intransigent insularity is not always a virtue, let alone helpful.

As Jews streamed out of the ghettos torn down by benevolent Napoléonic decree, their new-found and well-earned freedom also unleashed the throbbing Judenschmerz (“Jewish pain”) which afflicted so many nineteenth-century European Jews. The natural human urge to be accepted as full citizens of the wider society seized Jews across the Western world, most famously the poet Heinrich Heine. Medieval Christian hatred for Jewish particularism—not to mention Jewish particularism itself—was what had relegated Jews to the ghettos in the first place. It was universalism, both political and spiritual, which had freed the Jews. Therefore, universalism was, as Heine wrote in speaking of his nominal conversion to Christianity, “the admission ticket to European civilization.”

Yet, indeed, Jewish tradition is defined by particularism. From idolatry down to tattoos, Judaism forbids much of the outer world’s trappings. Furthermore, Judaism is far more than just a religion. “Judaism,” as Alan Dershowitz writes in his book The Case for Peace, “is a civilization that began as a religion” (p. 32). In other words, “Judaism” is like a button with a pull-down menu on a website, including the protruding list of

Religion—apart from alphabetical position—is only “last” on this list because it is the seed from which all the others germinate. Yet, a plant is not only its roots. An infection which enters through the farthest leaves can poison an entire tree if left untreated or unpruned. Judaism is not simply a corpus of books which can be left in a rabbinic library and divorced from life. Whether a Jew is Charedi or an atheist, it is an undeniable fact that these nine aspects of Jewishness form a self-contained solar system of planets which, like the bodies which orbit our Sun, make up a whole.

In the realm of politics, this means that Jews, put bluntly, are not in need of the nations’ failed ideas. This is to say that Judaism, while open-minded and welcoming, is an entity unto itself, and does not require fundamental transformation.

This does not mean that Judaism is required to exist in a vacuum. Particularism should never be confused with Nation of Islam-style separatism. One way to put it is the difference between acculturation and assimilation.

To acculturate is to responsibly absorb those aspects of the host culture which are non-threatening to one’s particularism, or at least to admire what may even be treif with a knowledge that it is treif in the first place. One pledges allegiance to the host society, abides by its statutes, becomes educated in its culture, and is able to enjoy what one can. One can even admire the exquisite art of the pagan ancient world in a museum so long as one knows full well that such paintings and statues are but lifeless things of wood and stone. One discriminates between what is holy and what is not, and has the knowledge and maturity to know avodah zarah when it presents itself.

To assimilate is completely different. In a Jewish context, assimilation is the explicit rejection of one’s discriminating faculties. There is no difference between what is holy and unholy. The many gods of the past and present—celebrities and politicians included—are not mortal or dead, but ever-living deities. The Jewish people—with their culture, ethnicity, geography, history, language, law, nationhood, philosophy, and religion—first became a people when God “married” them with the Covenant of Sinai. God proclaimed that His “bride” would love no other from that day to this, and He would refrain likewise. Assimilation is the rejection of God’s embrace and a divinely inspired heritage which has miraculously survived century after century of typically lethal threats to its continued existence.

Jews, put bluntly, are not in need of the nations’ failed ideas.

Jews, therefore, have a responsibility to preserve that unique civilization. And, in doing so, have the discernment and wisdom to learn from history’s lessons. One of the most important lessons is the disaster of assimilation into the fraudulent tolerance of secular leftist ideology.

Judaism vs. Socialism

The profound social upheavals of the eighteenth century’s final years laid before Western European Jews their first chance to grapple with the choice between acculturation and assimilation. It was partially for assimilation into this new, post-Biblical world of “universal” morality that Heine reluctantly bought his admission ticket in 1825. And there was a new political force circling Europe: socialism.

“Judaism,” however, “is not communism,” wrote the late Rabbi Jonathan Sacks in a commentary to Parashat Kedoshim in the Book of Va-Yik’ra (Leviticus):

The concept of equality we find in the Torah specifically and Judaism generally is not an equality of wealth.… Nor is it an equality of power: Judaism is not anarchy. It is fundamentally an equality of dignity. We are all equal citizens in the nation whose sovereign is God.

The piteous irony lost on many Jews over the past two centuries is that Sacks’ sage words and the great literati of socialism are in complete agreement on this point in particular.

Most European anti-capitalism was drenched in anti-Jewish bigotry from its genesis in the Middle Ages. In the lands of Akh’kenaz (today’s central Germany and northern France), market economics had always been deeply and derisively associated with Jews. Jewish communities were mostly situated in towns, as owning and working farmland was sometimes forbidden and always impractical given the constant danger of expulsion. Pressed by Church decree into money-lending, banking, and trading within largely agrarian societies, Jews became synonymous in many envious Christians’ minds with the idea of profit without labor. We take it for granted today that most vendors buy inventory which they did not grow or craft and sell it for a profit, but, prior to the nineteenth century, most Europeans’ contact with trade was through selling surplus crops or crafted objects produced with their own physical toil. From their perspective, the most noticeable exceptions to this rule were the people the Church had raised them to damn as their savior’s murderers and the seed of the Father of Lies.

It is no surprise, then, that the egalitarian promises of the eighteenth century, at best, proved disappointing for many European Jews. In the German states especially, the “new” epoch which so many Jews, like the socialist Heine himself, hoped would free them from medieval hatreds wasted little pity on them. In his classic 1992 study Wagner: Race and Revolution, the late scholar of anti-Semitism Paul Lawrence Rose (1944–2014) demonstrates the sad truth that almost nothing had changed for the better by Heine’s time:

In this revolutionary faith, as in the old Christian one that it was superseding, the Jews played a crucial symbolic role. The Jews represented, not only in theory but in real life, precisely that enslavement of the human spirit from which the German Revolution promised redemption. The Jews were the epitome of unfree mankind, bound to fearful, self-interested, irrational obedience to a God whom they could not understand…. [Immanuel] Kant dismissed Judaism as ‘not really a religion at all, but merely a union of a number of people’…. The fastidiously critical philosopher could, when it came to the subject of the Jews, write without any critical compunction what has been called the most antisemitic page in world literature: ‘A nation of usurers… bound together by a superstition… outwitting the people amongst whom they find shelter… A whole nation of pure merchants as non-productive members of society… They make the slogan “let the buyer beware” their highest principle in their dealings with us.’

p. 7.

It must first be clarified, though, that the dawn of the modern age was marked by two “Enlightenments”: one—whose progeny is the pragmatic, humane, rooted, civic liberalism foundational to the American Constitution—native to John Locke, Adam Smith, and Edmund Burke’s England and Scotland; the other—characterized by the Manichean quest for utopia—to Rousseau and Robespierre’s France and the pre-Bismarckian German states. One led to societies which, at worst, somewhat acknowledged Jews’ value as citizens, allowed for the free and full practice of Judaism, relegated hatred of Jews to the lowest of temperatures, and allowed Jews to flourish without the fear of Russian-style state-directed violence. The other, in the Germanic context especially, associated Jews and the God of Israel with everything blocking mankind from a perfect world of “spiritual” freedom from the confines of morality and the corrupted physical world itself. While the history of English political thought can arguably be summarized as a practical yet colorful search for “what works,” on the Continent, philosophers instead yearned for an idyllic world of amoral ecstasy always inches from the grasp of a god-like, absolutist despot. This hatred of the world as it is and revolutionary thirst for a totalitarian earthly paradise, so characteristic of the Franco-German Enlightenment, was thus a natural first step towards the development of modern socialism.

Indeed, the falsely labeled “liberalism” associated with Kant, which some scholars recognize as indispensable to later socialist doctrine, was a rich well of anti-Jewish prejudice as antique and reactionary as every idea it sought to supplant. Kantian philosopher Jakob Friedrich Fries (1773–1843) railed against the peril of Jewish assimilation and called for a return of the medieval laws mandating that Jews wear distinguishing badges on their clothing. As Rose documents, his 1816 polemic On the Danger Posed by the Jews to German Well-Being and Character demanded the “extermination of this Jewish commercial caste” (p. 13). Through his professorship at the University of Jena, Fries later helped instigate the anti-Semitic “Hep-Hep” riots of 1819, a pogrom aimed at crushing Jewish demands for emancipation which spread across Germany for more than two months and even bled into Denmark and Poland.

Another passionately anti-Semitic Kantian was Fries’s mentor, proto-socialist Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762–1814). A seemingly contradictory figure, who was both a revolutionary Jacobin and a founding father of German nationalism, Fichte held that “free” moral reasoning would liberate humanity from Jewish-imposed darkness. In his Closed Economic State (1800), he argued for an autarkic national community in which the state created perfect equality through price controls and cutting off foreign trade, a proposal which some recent scholarship suggests influenced Stalin’s policy of protectionist collectivization. Yet Fichte also wrote the Contribution to the Correct Understanding of the French Revolution. In this far-reaching treatise, he claimed that the Germans, the true chosen people, had been “crucified” by the Jews, whom he caricatured (with a straight pen) as European man’s chief oppressor and the most primitive of political reactionaries. He also, as Rose quotes him, “joked” that, “As to giving them civil rights, I see no way other than that of some night cutting off their heads and attaching in their place others in which there is not a single Jewish idea.” This he wrote in 1793, the year of the guillotine. Fichte’s ghoulish fantasy, Rose believes, greatly amused Hitler, who remarked “in Mein Kampf that holding down several thousand of the chosen people’s heads under poison gas in World War I might have made the war worthwhile” (p. 9).

Most European anti-capitalism was drenched in anti-Jewish bigotry from its genesis in the Middle Ages.

With the Industrial Revolution—a relatively late-comer to the areas in which most European Jews lived—and all its associated traumas, demonization of Jews in the name of the swelling urban poor quarters grew louder and louder. Jewish factory owners, it was claimed, were the ones most responsible for working honest former peasants to death while they lived in luxury, and Jewish merchants sold near-worthless goods for far more than their true price. Perhaps no strain of socialism would do more to spread such conspiracy theories throughout the century of emancipation and beyond than Marxist socialism.

Marx—in contrast to his friend Heine’s post-baptismal regret and lifelong identity crisis—showed no ambivalence in repudiating and slandering his Jewish origins to the uttermost. Arguably influenced somewhat by Fichte—indeed, Marxists.org proudly hosts some of his writings—and very much so by Kant, Marx, born to a family of converted Jews, “emancipated” himself from his Jewishness by championing his own ideology’s inherent anti-Semitism. What is taught in neither universities nor Hebrew schools today is that Marx was himself a virulent racist who lavished upon his (former) fellow Jews nothing less than the most maniacal contempt. In his 1843 screed “On the Jewish Question,” Marx declared “Money” to be “the jealous god of Israel”; that “the monotheism of the Jew” is a squalid, idolatrous tyranny “which makes even the lavatory an object of divine law”; the “Jewish religion” rejects “man as an end in himself”; “Huckstering” is the Jew’s “worldly religion”; and that, in the end, “the emancipation of the Jews is the emancipation of mankind from Judaism.” Marx himself unmistakably characterizes the Jewish people as a whole—not just “capitalists”—as the supreme masterminds of economic injustice. In a bizarre and venomous passage in Das Kapital, he writes that “The capitalist knows that all commodities, however scurvy they may look, or however badly they may smell, are in faith and in truth money, inwardly circumcised Jews, and what is more, a wonderful means whereby out of money to make more money.”

If Jews, as Marx believed, are themselves the heart of the bourgeoisie, and said bourgeoisie must be overthrown by any and all means—violent revolution both included and prescribed—then the only possible conclusion, truly, is the unthinkable. In a nightmarish allusion to events in his native Germany precisely one century after “On the Jewish Question,” Marx’s vision of utopia (like Fries’s before him) cannot logically be described as anything less than a world without Jews.

Despite Marx’s central (and subsequently airbrushed) place in the history of secular anti-Semitism, a small but vociferous group of European Jews beset with Judenschmerz found themselves drawn to his message of an atheist renaissance in which “all hitherto existing society” was erased. Exploited and oppressed for centuries, Jews frustrated with the burden of being Jewish saw in Marxism an extraordinary opportunity: a revolution against the established European order which had so degraded them, and an escape from the ranks of their despised people.

Having fled the clutches of their religious heritage, many Jewish Marxists imitated their role model and set about destroying any connection to their own heritage. As Natan Sharansky—perhaps the most famous and heroic Jewish victim of Marx’s political delusions—wrote with Gil Troy in Tablet in 2017:

Those Jews who wanted to join the global communist revolution to change the world felt that they had to prove themselves by denouncing their people still living in their shtetls, their small, cloistered Jewish communities. One archetypal such Jewish radical was the German Marxist Rosa Luxemburg. Swept up by what we could call the critical class theory of her day, seeing the entire world through the Marxian lens of class struggle in the hope of bringing equality to all, Luxemburg, like many Jews of her day, was happy to jettison her Jewish particularism to fulfill her universal vision.

…Some radicals even deemed the pogroms and other Jew-bashing outbursts necessary chapters in the “class struggle”—the violent birth of a new and better world.

Luxemburg—most infamous for her unironic maxim of “socialism or barbarism”—cruelly denounced her own Jewishness to the point of refusing to pity Jewish victims of both communist and tsarist pogroms. “I have no room in my heart for Jewish suffering,” Luxemburg snarled to a somewhat less self-loathing friend in 1917. “Why do you pester me with Jewish troubles? I feel closer to the wretched victims of the rubber plantations of Putumayo or the Negroes in Africa.… I have no separate corner in my heart for the ghetto.” Luxemburg’s zeal soon proved as suicidal in practice as it was in theory. During the communist uprising against the post-war German government in 1919, she would be captured, tortured, and murdered by members of the government-backed Freikorps, a paramilitary gang of re-mobilized veterans who believed that traitorous Jews like her had sealed Germany’s defeat in the Great War. Many Freikorps paramilitaries would later join the National Socialist German Workers Party, and, 14 years later, eventually succeed in overthrowing the Weimar Republic where their Marxist rivals had failed. To them, Luxemburg’s indifference to “Jewish suffering” mattered for nothing.

Still, the greatest failure was the most obvious. Many Jews had ignored more than a century of warning signs. Socialist and supposedly “liberal” revolutionary philosophers had spent generations making clear that Jews as Jews were not welcome in their world-to-come. Their culture was degenerate and miserly; their ethnicity was racially poisonous; their current geographical residence should be rid of them; their history was one of just and deserved suffering; their language was embarrassing and bizarre; their laws were backward, primitive, morally repellant, idolatrous, and a present danger to their neighbors; their national identity, or lack thereof, was a threat to all others; their philosophy of life was, at best, irrelevant, at worst, asinine; and their religion, the very fount of their civilization, was obsolete, evil, and a menace to all mankind.

Even so, some Jews still felt compelled to prefer anti-Jewish socialism over Judaism anyway. In fact, even more nonsensically, some would, out of zeal for socialism, exactly contradict what socialists had been angrily disproving for a century: that socialism was Judaism. In later years, Jews like these, especially leftist rabbis from the Reform and Reconstructionist movements in the United States, sought to conflate the ethical values of Tanakh’ with counterfeit, communist ones. As if to justify their rejection of their own Jewishness to themselves, they maintained that their treason was in the service of the inheritance they had abandoned. Translated into Marxist language, the words of Amos and Isaiah become demands for “social justice” and wealth redistribution, tzedakah an omnipotent state’s responsibility to coercively “care” for the people, and tikun olam a mandate to remake the world in the image of one which could never be. It is true that the State of Israel was founded by utopian socialists, but Zionist socialism uniquely affirmed (however superficially) the holistic reality of Jewish civilization, even though it rejected the Jewish religion (a near miss of too great an importance to discuss at present).

Yet, not only had they blindly ignored the unmentionable truth that their own ideology was originally invented as a revolution against Judaism, socialist Jews had missed the main point. Why would all of socialism’s great minds have spent so much time degrading Judaism as the root of all evil if it was not a full-fledged civilization unto itself? Should Kant, Fichte, Fries, Marx, and all the others’ vicious, obsessive protestations have been for nothing? And did attempting to conform to them do Jews any good?

“Jewish” or not, Jews will always be hated

The natural Jewish crisis of faith which followed the Holocaust only intensified the question of whether there was any point in remaining Jewish. Though it was the very fact that Jews were indeed so successfully assimilated into Western European society that the “racial” menace they posed warranted their extermination, many who survived or lived through that age remained unsure. Some, though completely secular, embraced Zionism as a middle ground between pride in their identity and observance of Jewish religious law. Some changed their names and quadrupled down upon their assimilation. Some, beset by a Judenschmerz more crippling than ever before, attempted to change the very definition of Jewishness itself.

All attempts at abandoning Jewish civilization in all its totality for something different have failed.

Perhaps the most tragic and fascinating individual example is of Jewish-born British writer Arthur Koestler (1905–1983). Koestler, a secular atheist, was a man of many ideologies, often contradictory. He was a passionate communist who felt the pre-war German Communist Party too moderate to effectively oppose the Nazis, yet became a resolute anti-communist once he realized the truth of Stalin’s terror. He reportedly bullied women with whom he committed adultery into having abortions and advocated for euthanasia while simultaneously opposing capital punishment. And he was a Zionist, but also wrote in his book Promise and Fulfillment that, in the Balfour Declaration, “one nation solemnly promised to a second nation the country of a third” (p. 4). While not technically a leftist, crucially, the theme of his life seemed to be that, because he was a Jew, he could not fit into any consistent community or way of seeing the world. Therefore, it seems, being Jewish was the negative common denominator without which he could be free.

Thus, in his later years, he lent his mind to the problem which had made Theodor Herzl the founder of Zionism: how to solve anti-Semitism. Where, in a fit of open-minded desperation, Herzl had once suggested that all European Jews be baptized, Koestler went even further. In his 1976 book The Thirteenth Tribe, he put forth a then little-known hypothesis that Ashkenazi Jews like him were not the seed of Abraham but of a now-vanished tribe of semi-nomadic Turkic warriors from the Central Asian steppes called the Khazars. The Khazars, it is alleged, converted to some form of Judaism around the year 740 C.E., supposedly to strengthen their position as a buffer kingdom between the Christian northwest and Islamic south. Koestler claimed that, with the collapse of their empire in the tenth century—which, at its height, stretched between the Black and Aral Seas—the Khazars migrated west and eventually became European Jewry.

The historical documentation for this claim is thin at best, the archaeological evidence confusing, and some scholars even believe (with good reason) that the Khazar conversion never happened at all. Similarly, almost no Turkic words are apparent in Yiddish (mostly a mix of medieval German and Hebrew), no Turkic elements (like the horse) appear in Ashkenazi Jewish culture, and, despite multiple attempts, no genetic evidence has been found to prove that Ashkenazi Jews bear any strong relation to Turkic Central Asians. In more recent years, DNA analysis has conclusively shown that Ashkenazi Jews, while possessing a small amount of non-Jewish European ancestry (enough to account for pale skin and so on), are directly and closely related not only to dark-skinned Jews from the Middle East and North Africa (whose Jewish pedigree has never been so questioned) but also to ancient Israelitic skeletal remains. Despite some questionably performed (and mendaciously exaggerated) research to the contrary, most studies indicate that Ashkenazi Jews have no significant connection to any Turkic populations, especially one which no longer exists.

Koestler’s intentions in writing The Thirteenth Tribe were not to denigrate his fellow Jews, as Marx had done in “On the Jewish Question.” Rather, his aim was to remove the classical reason for their victimhood. If, he believed, European Jews had no relation at all to the reviled “Pharisees” of the Christian Bible—the religious hatred which then morphed into the racial one—then the Western world would give a rational sigh and immediately renounce the age-old loathing into which it had poured so many centuries of energy.

Instead, the Khazar theory took on a life of its own. The book, dismissed by scholars at the time as hopelessly amateurish—National Review calling it “a work that has neither the value of a well-executed honest piece of scholarship nor the emotional appeal of a polemic—only the earmarks of a poorly researched and hastily written book”—sadly became a banner for the very racists and Christian anti-Semites Koestler had meant to silence. White supremacists and Christian identitarians seized on the book, using it as proof not only that Jews have no claim to the land of Israel but of Revelation 3:9, which speaks of the “synagogue of Satan,” made up of they who “say they are Jews, and are not, but do lie.” It also failed to counter semi-secular anti-Semitic libels, like those of Jewish financial criminality, governmental control, political disloyalty, racism, and sexual perversion. Today, hordes of anti-Jewish racists—Christian, Muslim, and Nazi alike (not excluding “Dr.” Mahmoud Abbas and Bashar al-Assad)—breathlessly proclaim that “Ashke-nazis” are Khazars, and the “Khazarian Mafia” rules the world. This well-intentioned proposal is now the “revelation” which encodes Jewish deceitfulness into the human genome. Surely, this proves, as Mark Twain said, that “All things are mortal but the Jews.”

Identity mistakenly identified

All attempts at abandoning Jewish civilization in all its totality for something different have failed. Christians refused to trust that converted Jews were true Christians and burned them as marranos; German Enlightenment luminaries saw Jews as backward primitives who retarded human progress; socialist and communist revolutionaries condemned Jews as thieves, reactionary tribalists, and capitalist puppet-masters; racial theorists cast Jews as disease-spreading vermin who must be cleansed from the globe before they infected the “pure” races; and post-modern racist Internet trolls combine all of their predecessors’ delusions to produce the average person’s X feed.

Since the Second World War, Zionism has, appropriately and despicably, been one of the left’s favorite whipping boys. Conceived in socialist ideals, the new State of Israel nevertheless presented a major threat to leftist and Soviet interests. The communists used an ideologically engineered strain of Jewish cultural identity as a means of uniting various ethnic minorities under socialist authority (“socialist in content, national in form”), but Zionism was a 100-meter dash too far. As an affirmation of Jewish particularism, Zionism would rouse Jews within the communist empire to self-determination; but, far more intolerably, it was a re-establishment of Jewish civilization, sovereign and total. Total, too, was the age-old socialist logic loop: immutable Jewish identity barred Jews from ever being true leftists, but Jews could not be allowed their full identity, even abroad, because their sense of identity would destroy socialism. Even worse, while socialists, all of Israel’s founders held deep pro-American sympathies, and the new state immediately placed itself on the Western side of the Cold War. Stalin had endorsed the 1947 U.N. partition as a way of annoying the British, and then supplied weapons to the Israeli army through his Czech vassals in the expectation that the government would, like conquered Poland, be “friendly” to the Soviet state, but the stoutly pro-Western Israelis “betrayed” the communists and linked arms with the United States.

A major milestone in the saga of Stalin’s descent into anti-Semitic madness was the knowledge that Polina Zhyemchuzhina, his (once) trusted foreign minister Vyachyeslav Molotov’s Jewish wife, held Zionist sympathies and enjoyed warm relations with Golda Meir. Having long hated and distrusted her for correctly suspecting that his own abuse led to his second wife’s suicide, Stalin directed the Politbyuro to expel Zhyemchuzhina from the party, a denunciation from which a grief-stricken Molotov abstained. In early 1949, she was arrested by the NKVD and sentenced to the Gulag, from which she, a life-long and loyal communist, was only released after Stalin’s death in 1953. Perhaps she, like so many, would eventually have been disgraced and exiled anyway, but this, undoubtedly, was because she was an unforgivably proud Jew.

Jews from Heine to Marx to Koestler have tried to be everything they are not: Christians, “enlightened” Europeans, socialists, “citizens of the world”—even Khazars. It has only brought them ruin: assimilation never pleases anyone. As in the play Leopoldstadt, despite being mostly baptized, Tom Stoppard’s irreligious family of semi-crypto-Jews are sent to Auschwitz and Dachau regardless.

Jews who have fully converted to the communist faith have embraced contemporary identity politics, not knowing that they were first popularized by none other than the man who sent them to the gas chambers. To Hitler, writes Jonah Goldberg in his masterpiece Liberal Fascism, “Jews were irredeemably Jews, no matter how well they spoke German. His allegiance, like that of all practitioners of identity politics, was to the iron cage of immutable identity” (p. 62). Leftist Jews in more recent decades thought that adoption of post-war CRT and DEI would create a niche in which they could be equal amongst “other” victimized groups who would mutually assist each other’s advancement. Instead, those groups betrayed them and supported their enemies. Whether anti-Semites espouse racial theory or not, Jews will always be Jews.

Jews have their own culture, ethnicity, geography, history, language, law, nationhood, philosophy, and religion. They can go to the opera, watch Seinfeld, salute the Stars and Stripes, and know their Rembrandts well, but they do not need the false salvation of “de-circumcision.” It is replacing the solution with the problem.


Judean Ethnicity: Rooted in Torah + History

What do they have in common? Though they live in far-flung countries all over the world, they share common ancestry with the ancient Israelites. Though they may speak different languages, they all share the Hebrew language.

Membership Required

You must be a subscriber to access this content

Already a member? Log in here

Ethnicity But Not Ethnocentric

to be a Jew goes beyond just your DNA. While no Jew can ever stop being a Jew according to our tradition and Jewish law, there are some basic minimums each Jew must uphold to be considered a Jew who is still part of the community.

Membership Required

You must be a subscriber to access this content

Already a member? Log in here

The Eternal Jew

A poem by Darren Glick

Membership Required

You must be a subscriber to access this content

Already a member? Log in here
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Please correct the marked field(s) below.