The Land that Remained in the People: Judean Peoplehood, Indigenous Belonging + the Meaning of Zionism
Before debating Zionism, before invoking the Holocaust, and before entering the controversies of contemporary politics, we must begin with a more fundamental question: Who are the Jewish people, and what is the history of our enduring connection to the Land of Israel?
We are a people. Jews are an ethnocultural people whose historical origins lie in the ancient Israelites and Judeans, whose civilization emerged in the Land of Israel, and whose history remains bound to that ancestral homeland. Judaism is our religion, but Jewish identity has never been confined to religious belief or observance. It encompasses ancestry, history, language, culture, collective memory, and national belonging. We did not begin as a religious community that later acquired an attachment to a place. Our peoplehood and our connection to the land are intertwined from the beginning of our history.
Our connection to the Land of Israel long preceded modern Zionism and the State of Israel. Zionism gave modern political expression to an existing historical connection; it did not create it.
The land is etched into the people.
It is present in Hebrew, in the names of ancient places, in our prayers and calendar, and in the historical record of the ancient Israelite and Judean civilizations from which the Jewish people emerged. It is present in Jerusalem, not merely as a sacred symbol, but as a city at the heart of Jewish history and collective memory.
We did not acquire this connection because we were persecuted. We carried it through centuries in which we lacked the political power to determine our own national future in our ancestral homeland. Our national belonging did not arise from suffering, nor does it depend on proving that we have suffered enough to deserve a homeland. We were a people long before modern anti-Semitism, long before the Holocaust, and long before modern Zionism gave our national aspirations a new political form.
Jewish history is a story of extraordinary continuity, not immobility. Across Europe, North Africa, the Middle East, and beyond, Jewish communities developed distinct languages, customs, and intellectual traditions. They absorbed influences, adapted to changing circumstances, and contributed to the civilizations around them without losing the historical continuity that bound them to one another and to their ancestral homeland. Empires fell, borders shifted, and communities were dispersed, yet the connection to the Land of Israel endured across generations.
That continuity has a dimension beyond cultural memory: it is also reflected in ancestry. Modern genetic research has found evidence of shared ancestry among many Jewish populations, including ancestry connected to the Levant, alongside the effects of migration and admixture over centuries. Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Mizrachi Jews have distinct population histories, yet research reveals patterns of relatedness across many of these communities. We are a displaced family whose very biology remembers home.
Nor does the evidence rest on ancestry and memory alone. Archaeology provides a substantial material record of ancient Israelite and Judean life in the Land of Israel: inscriptions, buildings, coins, and other remains that illuminate the civilizations from which Jewish history emerged.
The Tel Dan Stele, discovered in northern Israel and dating to the ninth century B.C.E., contains an Aramaic reference widely read as the “House of David” (בֵּית דָּוִד), providing important extra-Biblical evidence of a Davidic dynasty.
Jerusalem’s Siloam Inscription, associated with a water tunnel generally dated to the eighth century B.C.E., describes workers excavating from opposite directions and meeting within the rock. Written in ancient Hebrew script, it preserves a vivid record of life in Jerusalem more than 2,700 years ago.
Ancient Judean coinage offers further evidence of national identity. Coins bearing the inscription “Y-H-D” attest to the name of the province of Yehud under Persian administration. Centuries later, during the First Jewish-Roman War (66–70 C.E.) and the Bar Kokhba revolt (132–135 C.E.), Jewish authorities issued coins inscribed with phrases such as “Freedom of Zion,” “The Redemption of Israel,” and “For the Freedom of Jerusalem.” These coins expressed Jewish political aspirations and the desire to reclaim sovereignty in a land bound to Jewish history.
Rome could destroy the Temple, suppress revolts, and scatter Jewish communities across its empire, but it could not sever the bond with our ancestral homeland. Through Torah and Talmud, prayer and law, Hebrew and ritual, the land remained a living inheritance. What political power could no longer sustain, Jewish civilization continued to carry.
Zionism was the modern political expression of that extraordinary continuity: not the invention of the Jewish people’s connection to its homeland, but the effort to give that connection renewed national and physical expression. For generations, the Jewish people had carried the land within its civilization. Zionism sought to re-establish Israel as our homeland in which our civilization could once again shape its collective future.
No single artifact tells the story of an entire people. But archaeology, language, literature, ritual, and the evidence of continuing Jewish life together illuminate a connection that modern Zionism did not create. Jewish communities continued to live in the Land of Israel under successive periods of foreign rule, even as their numbers, circumstances, and political standing changed. Their presence did not mean uninterrupted sovereignty; the loss of sovereignty did not erase their place in the history of their ancestral homeland.
The Land of Israel is not simply the place Jews remember. It is part of the history through which the Jewish people remembers itself.
Our relationship with this land is ancestral, historical, cultural, and religious, sustained across generations through language, ritual, learning, and collective memory.
The Jewish calendar offers a vivid expression of this continuity. Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot preserve associations with the agricultural seasons, pilgrimage, and the geography of the Land of Israel. Across continents and centuries, Jewish communities continued to observe these festivals, carrying the rhythms and memories of their ancestral land into places far removed from it.
Our national belonging did not arise from suffering, nor does it depend on proving that we have suffered enough to deserve a homeland. We were a people long before modern anti-Semitism, long before the Holocaust, and long before modern Zionism gave our national aspirations a new political form.
Hebrew offers another powerful expression of Jewish continuity. It remained the language of Jewish scripture, prayer, interpretation, and intellectual life even as its everyday use changed over the centuries. Its revival as a modern spoken language transformed this shared inheritance into a language of public life, giving ancient Jewish civilization renewed expression in modern national life.
Jerusalem remained at the heart of Jewish consciousness across generations. It lived in prayers, poetry, wedding ceremonies, and the words spoken at the conclusion of the Passover Seder: “Next year in Jerusalem.” The aspiration endured even among generations who had never seen the city.
Jewish communities continued to live in Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, Hebron, and elsewhere under changing political authorities. Their numbers and circumstances varied, but their presence formed part of the continuing history of Jewish life in our ancestral homeland.
Together, language, ritual, historical memory, communal life, and material evidence reveal the continuity of a people whose identity is historical, cultural, and national as well as religious.
A Charedi Jew in Jerusalem, a secular Jew in Tel Aviv, and an atheist Jew in New York may inhabit profoundly different intellectual and spiritual worlds. They may disagree about G-d, religious observance, politics, and the meaning of Jewish life. Yet each may understand themselves as belonging to the Jewish people. Their differences do not erase the history they share.
We are a people, not merely a faith.
The land endured in Jewish consciousness even when most Jews lived elsewhere. It was carried in words, practices, names, and expectations. The loss of political sovereignty altered the conditions of Jewish life; it did not dissolve the people whose history had begun there. Remembering a homeland and possessing the political freedom to shape its future are not the same thing.
For centuries, Jews preserved a distinctive collective identity while living under the authority of other states and empires. They developed institutions, cultivated intellectual traditions, and contributed enormously to the societies around them. Jewish life sometimes flourished; at other times, it faced discrimination, exclusion, expulsion, and violence. Throughout these changing circumstances, Jews generally lacked the political agency to determine their collective national future.
Emerging in the nineteenth century amid persistent anti-Semitism, modern Zionism sought to realize a longstanding aspiration: Jewish national self-determination in the Land of Israel.
Persecution helps explain the urgency of modern Zionism. It does not exhaust its meaning. To understand Zionism only as a response to anti-Semitism is to begin the story too late, making Jewish national self-determination appear to be a conditional remedy, justified only by the severity of Jewish suffering. The Jewish people’s national aspirations did not originate in persecution, and their legitimacy should not depend on proving how terribly Jews have suffered.
This brings us to a fundamental question of liberal political thought: can a philosophy committed to individual freedom also recognize the legitimate national aspirations of the ethnicities to whom individuals belong?
Modern Zionism can be understood within the intellectual tradition of liberalism, particularly its commitments to freedom of conscience, equality before the law, protection against arbitrary power, and self-government. These principles provide a compelling philosophical framework for understanding the claims of national liberation movements.
Human beings do not arrive in the world as isolated individuals without history. We inherit languages, traditions, and cultural identities. We belong to communities whose stories began before our birth and whose futures extend beyond our lives. We may reinterpret these inheritances, reject parts of them, or choose how to relate to them, but we do not create them from nothing. For centuries, the Jewish people lived under foreign rule, often without the political power to determine their collective future. Zionism emerged as a movement to reclaim the Jewish people’s right to national self-determination.
John F. Kennedy articulated a connection between Zionism and universal liberty in his 1960 address to the Zionist Organization of America, describing friendship for Israel as “a national commitment.” Martin Luther King, Jr. likewise connected Israel’s security with democratic values. Addressing the Rabbinical Assembly in 1968, he called Israel “one of the great outposts of democracy in the world.” King’s opposition to anti-Semitism also extended to anti-Zionism, as reflected in a 1967 conversation later recounted by sociologist Seymour Martin Lipset. Together, these statements illustrate how prominent American advocates of liberal and democratic ideals understood the significance of Israel, although their views should be understood in their historical context.
A universal principle cannot be universal only when its application is convenient.
Zionism belongs in a serious conversation about liberalism because it raises a fundamental question for liberal political thought: does freedom mean only the protection of individuals within existing political arrangements, or can it also include the capacity of a people to shape its own national future? For the Jewish people, that future has a particular historical geography. It is the Land of Israel.
National self-determination does not require a people to be culturally uniform, religiously observant, or politically unanimous. It recognizes that a people with a shared history and collective identity has a legitimate interest in shaping its own future. For the Jewish people, that aspiration is inseparable from the land in which our civilization emerged and with which our collective memory remains bound.
The Jewish experience also challenges the assumption that participation in a wider civilization must eventually mean the erosion of a distinctive identity. Jewish history is not a story of isolation. Jews have encountered other civilizations, absorbed influences, debated inherited traditions, and contributed to the societies in which they lived. These encounters have enriched Jewish intellectual, artistic, scientific, and political life. The question has never been whether Jews should engage with the wider world. It is whether engagement requires self-erasure.
The ancient encounter with Hellenistic civilization offers a revealing perspective. Following Alexander the Great’s conquests, Greek language, philosophy, education, and cultural practices spread throughout the eastern Mediterranean. Many Jews engaged deeply with Hellenistic culture, which profoundly shaped Jewish life.
Jewish responses varied. Some sought fuller assimilation into the dominant culture, even attempting to reverse their circumcisions to participate in Greek athletic institutions. They traded an eternal heritage for ephemeral social currency. Yet the conflicts that culminated in the Maccabean revolt reflected competing visions of Jewish life, not simply a struggle between everything Jewish and everything foreign.
Rome could destroy the Temple, suppress revolts, and scatter Jewish communities across its empire, but it could not sever the bond with our ancestral homeland.
The lesson is not that cultural influences must be rejected. Jewish civilization has never developed in isolation. The question is whether a people retains the confidence and freedom to decide what it will adopt, what it will transform, and what it must preserve.
Across the centuries, we, the Jewish people, accomplished something extraordinary: we endured. The empires that ruled over us rose and fell. We learned their languages, engaged with their ideas, contributed to their achievements, and made our homes within their societies. We were shaped by the worlds we inhabited, yet never wholly dissolved into them. Dynasties collapsed. Borders were redrawn. And still, we endured.
The civilizations changed. The world changed. The Judean people remained.
The question of how a people can belong fully to the wider world without losing its distinctive identity remains urgent in the modern West. Jews have helped shape Western intellectual, scientific, artistic, and political life. We can embrace its achievements, defend its liberal principles, and participate fully in its future without setting aside our history or Jewish national belonging. We need not choose between Jewish particularity and universal human dignity, or confuse integration with assimilation. A people can be open to the world without becoming indistinguishable from it.
The danger of over-assimilation is not that Jews learn from other civilizations, speak other languages, or make homes in other countries. It is that the desire to belong can pressure Jews to minimize, conceal, or abandon the inheritance that makes their identity distinctive.
In its contemporary form, this can be understood as a kind of Neo-Hellenism: the assumption that Jewish identity becomes more acceptable when its distinctive history and national aspirations are softened or set aside. Under this logic, Jews may participate in universal causes, provided their own particularity does not demand recognition. But universal human dignity does not require the erasure of the particular communities through which people experience history, culture, and belonging. Jews should not have to justify their own collective identity in order to affirm the rights and dignity of others.
We can be citizens of other countries, participate in other cultures, and contribute to the societies we call home. We can value their freedoms, criticize our own communities, reconsider our traditions, and disagree with one another. None of this requires us to deny our origins or abandon our relationship with our ancestral homeland. We can enter the wider world without disappearing into it.
The question is not whether Jews can belong to the West. We already do. It is why that belonging should require us to minimize our historical inheritance or apologize for our national aspirations.
A people should not have to become less itself to belong.
We did not become a people through persecution or acquire an ancestral homeland because we needed refuge. We were a people before modern Zionism, and our connection to the Land of Israel preceded the modern state.
On May 14, 1948, the establishment of the State of Israel gave Jewish national aspirations modern sovereign expression. Israel’s Declaration of Independence identified the Land of Israel as the birthplace of the Jewish people, where its spiritual, religious, and national identity had taken shape, and connected that historical relationship to the restoration of Jewish political freedom.
The state did not create the Jewish people, invent Hebrew, or establish Jerusalem’s place in Jewish memory. These were inheritances of a much older history.
What changed in 1948 was the political condition in which that history could unfold. Hebrew, preserved across generations in scripture, prayer, and learning, became a language of public institutions, education, government, and everyday life. Jewish cultural life could develop within a sovereign national home, and a people long accustomed to living across borders it did not control could assume direct political responsibility for its collective future.
Israel’s establishment was more than the creation of a state. It was the modern political expression of an enduring national identity.
The distinction between a people and its state remains essential. The Jewish people predates Israel, and Jewish life extends far beyond its borders. Diaspora communities remain vital to Jewish history and contemporary culture. Israel does not erase this reality; it gives sovereign expression to Jewish national life alongside the many ways Jewish identity flourishes elsewhere.
We are Israel.
Not because every Jew lives within Israel’s borders. Not because every Jew shares the same beliefs, traditions, or political convictions. Not because Jewish history is simple or the responsibilities of sovereignty small.
We are Israel because the history of the Jewish people and the Land of Israel are inseparable. Our connection is ancestral, historical, cultural, and religious, carried through language, memory, ritual, and generations of Jewish life. The loss of sovereignty did not erase our peoplehood. Time did not erase our origins.
We are Israel because we are a people, not merely a faith. Judaism is our religion, but Judean identity extends beyond religious observance. It belongs to the Charedi Jew in Jerusalem, the secular Jew in Tel Aviv, and the atheist Jew in New York; to Jews in Israel and those who make their homes elsewhere. Our differences do not erase the history we share.
We are Israel because we can participate in the wider world without surrendering our inheritance. We can be particular without being insular, rooted without being closed, and committed to our people’s future while recognizing the dignity and rights of others.
We are Israel because Zionism gives political expression to a fundamental conviction: that the Jewish people, like other peoples, is entitled to determine its national future in its ancestral homeland.
The land is etched into the people.
Not only in ancient stones and inscriptions, but in our language, traditions, place names, and the history through which we understand ourselves.
We did not become a people through persecution or acquire an ancestral homeland because we needed refuge. We were a people before modern Zionism, and our connection to the Land of Israel preceded the modern state.
The story of the Jewish people cannot begin with the Holocaust or be reduced to today’s political controversies. Those events matter profoundly, but they do not define our origins or exhaust the meaning of our national aspirations.
We are Israel: a people shaped by history, sustained through change, and responsible for the future we create.
The story did not begin in 1948.
And it does not end there.